Bjerager Marianne, Palshof Torben, Dahl Ronald, Olesen Frede
Aarhus Universitet, Institut og Forskningsenhed for Almen Praksis, og Arhus Sygehus, Onkologisk Afdeling, Arhus C.
Ugeskr Laeger. 2006 Apr 3;168(14):1443-7.
The aim of this study was to determine whether there is a nihilistic attitude towards diagnosing lung cancer among Danish general practitioners (GPs) and to obtain the GPs' evaluation of the present approach to lung cancer diagnosis.
A questionnaire was sent to 1,186 randomly selected GPs. Most of the questions addressed the possibilities of improving primary prevention, GPs' attitudes towards diagnosing lung cancer, their opinions about waiting times and their clinical practice.
A total of 848 (71%) completed the questionnaire. Only 12% agreed with the statement that the prognosis for lung cancer is so unfavourable that there is no hurry to diagnose the disease, while 22% agreed to the statement that diagnostic delay rarely means anything for the prognosis. About half of the GPs found the diagnostic period too long. There were, however, wide variations among the different counties in Denmark. The majority of GPs followed the recommendations of the Danish Lung Cancer Group for diagnosing lung cancer, especially the elderly GPs, who were also more inclined to make follow-up appointments after lung infections. More than one in every four practitioners was reluctant to use the word "cancer" in referrals to hospitals or for investigation.
The study showed that Danish GPs do not have a nihilistic attitude towards diagnosing lung cancer and that elderly practitioners are more careful about diagnosing lung cancer. GPs' satisfaction with waiting times varies widely among the different counties in Denmark. Many practitioners were reluctant to use the word "cancer" in referrals.
本研究的目的是确定丹麦全科医生(GP)在诊断肺癌方面是否存在虚无主义态度,并获取全科医生对当前肺癌诊断方法的评价。
向1186名随机挑选的全科医生发送了一份问卷。大多数问题涉及改善一级预防的可能性、全科医生对诊断肺癌的态度、他们对等待时间的看法以及他们的临床实践。
共有848名(71%)完成了问卷。只有12%的人同意肺癌预后非常不利以至于无需急于诊断这种疾病的说法,而22%的人同意诊断延迟对预后几乎没有影响的说法。大约一半的全科医生认为诊断期过长。然而,丹麦不同郡县之间存在很大差异。大多数全科医生遵循丹麦肺癌小组关于诊断肺癌的建议,尤其是老年全科医生,他们也更倾向于在肺部感染后安排随访预约。每四名从业者中就有超过一人在转诊至医院或进行检查时不愿使用“癌症”这个词。
该研究表明丹麦全科医生在诊断肺癌方面不存在虚无主义态度,并且老年从业者在诊断肺癌时更加谨慎。丹麦不同郡县的全科医生对等待时间的满意度差异很大。许多从业者在转诊时不愿使用“癌症”这个词。