Körblein Alfred
Munich Environmental Institute, Munich, Germany.
Arch Environ Health. 2004 Nov;59(11):604-9. doi: 10.1080/00039890409603440.
Using trend analysis, the author sought a possible association between perinatal mortality rates in West Germany, 1955-1993, and the fallout from atmospheric nuclear weapons testing in the years 1952-1993. The regression model used a continuously falling trend and a superimposed extra term that reflects the average strontium content in pregnant women. Mortality rates show an upward deviation that peaked in 1970. The model attributes more than 100,000 excess perinatal deaths to strontium in the fallout. The dose-response curve is curvilinear with a power of dose of 1.81 +/- 0.23. In addition, using a combined regression model, the author analyzed the two data subsets of perinatal mortality (i.e., stillbirth rate and early neonatal mortality). The strontium effect is 3.4 times greater on early infant deaths than on stillbirths. According to the prevailing wisdom, the fetus is protected against damage from ionizing radiation by a threshold dose of 50-200 mSv, but the doses from strontium in the fallout were well below 1 mSv/yr in Germany. The results reported here seem to contradict the existence of a threshold dose for perinatal mortality at low doses.
作者运用趋势分析方法,探寻了1955 - 1993年西德围产期死亡率与1952 - 1993年期间大气核武器试验沉降物之间可能存在的关联。回归模型采用了持续下降的趋势以及一个反映孕妇体内平均锶含量的叠加额外项。死亡率呈现出向上的偏差,并于1970年达到峰值。该模型将超过10万例围产期额外死亡归因于沉降物中的锶。剂量 - 反应曲线呈曲线状,剂量幂为1.81±0.23。此外,作者使用组合回归模型分析了围产期死亡率的两个数据子集(即死产率和早期新生儿死亡率)。锶对早期婴儿死亡的影响比对死产的影响大3.4倍。根据普遍观点,胎儿受到50 - 200毫希沃特的阈值剂量保护,可免受电离辐射损害,但德国沉降物中锶的剂量每年远低于1毫希沃特。此处报告的结果似乎与低剂量围产期死亡率存在阈值剂量的观点相矛盾。