Stewart Ian, Webb Penelope M, Schluter Philip J, Fleming Lora E, Burns John W, Gantar Miroslav, Backer Lorraine C, Shaw Glen R
National Research Centre for Environmental Toxicology, University of Queensland, 39 Kessels Road, Coopers Plains, QLD 4108, Australia.
BMC Public Health. 2006 Apr 11;6:93. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-6-93.
Case studies and anecdotal reports have documented a range of acute illnesses associated with exposure to cyanobacteria and their toxins in recreational waters. The epidemiological data to date are limited; we sought to improve on the design of some previously conducted studies in order to facilitate revision and refinement of guidelines for exposure to cyanobacteria in recreational waters.
A prospective cohort study was conducted to investigate the incidence of acute symptoms in individuals exposed, through recreational activities, to low (cell surface area < 2.4 mm2/mL), medium (2.4-12.0 mm2/mL) and high (> 12.0 mm2/mL) levels of cyanobacteria in lakes and rivers in southeast Queensland, the central coast area of New South Wales, and northeast and central Florida. Multivariable logistic regression analyses were employed; models adjusted for region, age, smoking, prior history of asthma, hay fever or skin disease (eczema or dermatitis) and clustering by household.
Of individuals approached, 3,595 met the eligibility criteria, 3,193 (89%) agreed to participate and 1,331 (37%) completed both the questionnaire and follow-up interview. Respiratory symptoms were 2.1 (95%CI: 1.1-4.0) times more likely to be reported by subjects exposed to high levels of cyanobacteria than by those exposed to low levels. Similarly, when grouping all reported symptoms, individuals exposed to high levels of cyanobacteria were 1.7 (95%CI: 1.0-2.8) times more likely to report symptoms than their low-level cyanobacteria-exposed counterparts.
A significant increase in reporting of minor self-limiting symptoms, particularly respiratory symptoms, was associated with exposure to higher levels of cyanobacteria of mixed genera. We suggest that exposure to cyanobacteria based on total cell surface area above 12 mm2/mL could result in increased incidence of symptoms. The potential for severe, life-threatening cyanobacteria-related illness is likely to be greater in recreational waters that have significant levels of cyanobacterial toxins, so future epidemiological investigations should be directed towards recreational exposure to cyanotoxins.
病例研究和轶事报告记录了一系列与在娱乐水域接触蓝藻及其毒素相关的急性疾病。迄今为止的流行病学数据有限;我们试图改进一些先前开展的研究的设计,以便于修订和完善娱乐水域接触蓝藻的指南。
开展了一项前瞻性队列研究,以调查昆士兰东南部、新南威尔士州中部海岸地区以及佛罗里达州东北部和中部的湖泊及河流中,通过娱乐活动接触低(细胞表面积<2.4平方毫米/毫升)、中(2.4 - 12.0平方毫米/毫升)和高(>12.0平方毫米/毫升)水平蓝藻的个体出现急性症状的发生率。采用多变量逻辑回归分析;模型对地区、年龄、吸烟情况、哮喘、花粉症或皮肤病(湿疹或皮炎)既往史以及家庭聚类进行了调整。
在接触的个体中,3595人符合入选标准,3193人(89%)同意参与,1331人(37%)完成了问卷调查和随访访谈。接触高水平蓝藻的受试者报告呼吸道症状的可能性是接触低水平蓝藻受试者的2.1倍(95%置信区间:1.1 - 4.0)。同样,当对所有报告的症状进行分组时,接触高水平蓝藻的个体报告症状的可能性是接触低水平蓝藻个体的1.7倍(95%置信区间:1.0 - 2.8)。
接触较高水平的混合属蓝藻与轻微自限性症状(尤其是呼吸道症状)报告的显著增加有关。我们认为,基于总细胞表面积高于12平方毫米/毫升接触蓝藻可能会导致症状发生率增加。在含有大量蓝藻毒素的娱乐水域中,与蓝藻相关的严重、危及生命疾病的可能性可能更大,因此未来的流行病学调查应针对娱乐性接触蓝藻毒素展开。