Moncrieff Joanna
Department of Mental Health Science, University College London, Wolfson Building, 48 Riding House Street, London W1N 8AA, United Kingdom.
Med Hypotheses. 2006;67(3):517-23. doi: 10.1016/j.mehy.2006.03.009. Epub 2006 Apr 24.
In this paper, I argue that the problems that occur after discontinuation or reduction of long-term psychiatric drug treatment may be caused by the process of drug withdrawal itself, rather than representing the course of the underlying illness. Adverse effects induced by discontinuation of psychiatric medication include: (1) a somatic discontinuation syndrome that includes psychological symptoms which may be mistaken for relapse, (2) a rapid onset psychotic reaction after withdrawal of both conventional neuroleptic drugs and some atypicals, notably clozapine (sometimes referred to as supersensitivity psychosis), (3) a psychological reaction to withdrawal, which may be mistaken for relapse or may itself precipitate relapse, (4) a genuine relapse of the underlying condition precipitated by the process of withdrawal. The implications of these effects include the possibility that much of the research on maintenance treatment is flawed and that the recurrent nature of psychiatric conditions may sometimes be iatrogenic. If withdrawal induced adverse effects could be effectively managed, the success of drug discontinuation might be much greater than usually assumed and might outweigh the disadvantages of continued treatment.
在本文中,我认为长期精神科药物治疗中断或减量后出现的问题可能是由撤药过程本身引起的,而非代表潜在疾病的病程。停用精神科药物所致的不良反应包括:(1)躯体撤药综合征,其中包括可能被误认为是复发的心理症状;(2)停用传统抗精神病药物和某些非典型药物(尤其是氯氮平,有时称为超敏性精神病)后迅速出现的精神病性反应;(3)对撤药的心理反应,这可能被误认为是复发,或者本身可能促使复发;(4)撤药过程引发的潜在疾病真正复发。这些影响的意义在于,许多维持治疗的研究可能存在缺陷,而且精神疾病的复发性质有时可能是医源性的。如果能够有效管理撤药引起的不良反应,停药成功的可能性可能比通常认为的要大得多,且可能超过持续治疗的弊端。