Paz Isabel, Jones David, Byrne Gerry
Park Hospital for Children, Oxford, UK.
Curr Opin Psychiatry. 2005 Jul;18(4):411-21. doi: 10.1097/01.yco.0000172061.93896.26.
This review summarizes advances in our understanding of child maltreatment and the implications thereof for physical, psychological and social development, with special emphasis on mental health aspects.
Methodological problems persist. These may be related in part to an over-emphasis on type of maltreatment, to the detriment of consideration of degree and extent of maltreatment. They may also be related to inadequate application of a comprehensive model of maltreatment and its consequences. Recent studies underline the inter-relatedness and cross-over between different types of child maltreatment and family violence. Research also underlines the extent to which child maltreatment is a major public health crisis internationally. Effects are seen on physical health and development as well as mental health, and it is becoming increasingly evident that these outcomes are inextricably linked to one another. There are encouraging signs that certain interventions are effective.
There is a need for a more sophisticated model of child maltreatment that includes not only degree but also the extent to which basic developmental needs are overridden when children are maltreated, and that includes children's responses to maltreatment as a mediating influence. More studies are needed of samples of children who have been maltreated in order to gain a better understanding of how maltreatment distorts the trajectory of normal development. Crucially, we need more research on intervention, including both case management and psychological treatment approaches.
本综述总结了我们在理解儿童虐待及其对身体、心理和社会发展的影响方面取得的进展,特别强调了心理健康方面。
方法学问题依然存在。这些问题可能部分与过度强调虐待类型有关,从而忽视了对虐待程度和范围的考量。它们也可能与未能充分应用虐待及其后果的综合模型有关。近期研究强调了不同类型的儿童虐待与家庭暴力之间的相互关联性和交叉性。研究还强调了儿童虐待在国际上是一个重大公共卫生危机的程度。其影响体现在身体健康和发展以及心理健康方面,而且越来越明显的是,这些结果相互之间有着千丝万缕的联系。有令人鼓舞的迹象表明某些干预措施是有效的。
需要一个更完善的儿童虐待模型,该模型不仅要包括虐待程度,还要包括儿童受虐待时基本发展需求被忽视的程度,并且要将儿童对虐待的反应作为一种中介影响纳入其中。需要对受虐待儿童样本进行更多研究,以便更好地理解虐待如何扭曲正常发展轨迹。至关重要的是,我们需要更多关于干预措施的研究,包括个案管理和心理治疗方法。