Kazikdas K Cagdas, Serbetcioglu Bulent, Boyraz Ismail, Tugyan Kazim, Erbil Guven, Yilmaz Osman, Onal Kazim
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Ataturk Training and Research Hospital, and Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Dokuz Eylul University, Faculty of Medicine, Izmir, Turkey.
Otol Neurotol. 2006 Apr;27(3):303-7. doi: 10.1097/00129492-200604000-00003.
The goal of this experimental study was to investigate the specific effect of myringosclerosis on tympanograms in the tympanic membranes of myringotomized rats by using otomicroscopy, tympanometry, and histopathology.
Myringosclerosis is a common sequela of ventilation tube treatment of otitis media with effusion. The condition involves the hyalinization and calcification of the collagen layer in certain areas of the tympanic membrane. Previous animal experiments suggest an intimate relationship between the formation of myringosclerosis and an increased oxygen concentration in the environment of the wound after myringotomy. The result of a myringotomy therefore is an increased production of free oxygen radicals, initiating irreversible tissue damage involving fibrosis, hyalin degeneration, and finally apoptosis as observed in myringosclerosis. We propose an experimental model specific for creating sclerotic plaques solely on the tympanic membrane and for performing tympanometric measurements on this pure myringosclerosis model without creating any abnormality in the middle ear to test in what proportion myringosclerosis contributes to decrease of amplitude in tympanograms.
To assess the normal tympanometric values of Wistar albino rats, the pressure and peak admittance of the left middle ears were measured using a semiquantitative computerized clinical admittance meter using a sound frequency of 226 Hz. Twelve animals were randomly selected for the myringotomy group and perforations in the left ears were created. All tympanic membrane perforations in this group had healed and closed prior to the otomicroscopic examination and no pathologic reaction was observed in the external ear canals of rats. Otomicroscopic and tympanometric measurements were carried out on Day 15 and the degree of myringosclerosis was noted before the animals were killed. Twelve specimens in the myringotomy group were histopathologically examined for the presence of myringosclerotic plaques.
Under light microscopy, extensive sclerotic lesions were found in the tympanic membranes of the myringotomy group, and these sclerotic deposits were located in the lamina propria. The myringosclerosis occurred predominantly adjacent to the handle of the malleus, but also near the annular region. In all ears with myringosclerosis, the magnitude of the maximum admittance reduced to approximately 50% of the Day-0 values, and this reduction was statistically significant (Z=-3.061, p=0.002).
The present findings in this study are consistent with the fact that the movement of the tympanic membrane is hampered by lesions of sclerotic material, resulting in a decrease of amplitude in tympanograms (such as Type As) without any effusion or inflammation in the middle ear.
本实验研究的目的是通过耳显微镜检查、鼓室导抗测量和组织病理学,研究鼓膜切开术大鼠鼓膜中鼓膜硬化对鼓室导抗图的具体影响。
鼓膜硬化是分泌性中耳炎通气管治疗的常见后遗症。这种情况涉及鼓膜某些区域胶原层的透明化和钙化。先前的动物实验表明,鼓膜硬化的形成与鼓膜切开术后伤口环境中氧浓度升高密切相关。因此,鼓膜切开术的结果是游离氧自由基产生增加,引发不可逆的组织损伤,包括纤维化、透明变性,最终如鼓膜硬化中所见的细胞凋亡。我们提出一种实验模型,专门用于仅在鼓膜上形成硬化斑块,并在这个纯鼓膜硬化模型上进行鼓室导抗测量,而不引起中耳任何异常,以测试鼓膜硬化在多大程度上导致鼓室导抗图幅度降低。
为评估Wistar白化大鼠的正常鼓室导抗值,使用半定量计算机化临床导抗仪,以226Hz的声频测量左中耳的压力和峰值导纳。随机选择12只动物作为鼓膜切开术组,在左耳制造穿孔。该组所有鼓膜穿孔在耳显微镜检查前均已愈合和闭合,且在大鼠外耳道未观察到病理反应。在第15天进行耳显微镜检查和鼓室导抗测量,并在处死动物前记录鼓膜硬化程度。对鼓膜切开术组的12个标本进行组织病理学检查,以确定是否存在鼓膜硬化斑块。
在光学显微镜下,鼓膜切开术组的鼓膜发现广泛的硬化病变,这些硬化沉积物位于固有层。鼓膜硬化主要发生在锤骨柄附近,但也靠近环形区域。在所有有鼓膜硬化的耳朵中,最大导纳幅度降至约为第0天值的50%,且这种降低具有统计学意义(Z=-3.061,p=0.002)。
本研究的当前发现与以下事实一致,即硬化物质病变阻碍了鼓膜的运动,导致鼓室导抗图(如A型)幅度降低,而中耳无任何积液或炎症。