King Joseph T, Horowitz Michael B, Bissonette David J, Tsevat Joel, Roberts Mark S
Section of Neurosurgery, VA Connecticut Healthcare System, West Haven, Connecticut 06516, USA.
Neurosurgery. 2006 May;58(5):824-30; discussion 824-30. doi: 10.1227/01.NEU.0000209610.25882.54.
During diagnosis and treatment, patients with cerebral aneurysms receive complex medical information. To study what patients know about their condition, we compared patients' knowledge about their aneurysm-related medical history with information in the medical record.
Neurosurgery clinic outpatients with cerebral aneurysms were interviewed about their history of subarachnoid hemorrhage, number of aneurysms, aneurysm treatments, and treatment outcomes. Corresponding data were abstracted from the medical record by study personnel. We used kappa scores to assess the agreement between patient responses and the medical record.
The 178 study patients were predominantly women (71%), with a mean age of 54.4 years. The medical record showed that 56% of patients currently harbored an unsecured aneurysm, 53% had experienced a subarachnoid hemorrhage, 29% had multiple aneurysms, and 68% had undergone previous surgical or endovascular aneurysm treatment. Patient responses showed that, of the 100 patients with unsecured aneurysms, 33% were not aware that they harbored an unsecured aneurysm. Ninety percent of all patients knew whether they had experienced a subarachnoid hemorrhage (kappa = 0.81, near perfect agreement), 78% knew how many aneurysms they harbored (kappa = 0.57, moderate agreement), and 92% understood whether they had undergone previous aneurysm treatment (kappa = 0.82, near perfect agreement).
Most patients with cerebral aneurysms had an accurate understanding of many aspects of their aneurysm-related medical history. Of concern, patients were most often incorrect about the presence of an unsecured aneurysm, the issue most relevant to treatment decision-making and to their future risk of subarachnoid hemorrhage, stroke, and premature death.
在诊断和治疗过程中,脑动脉瘤患者会接收到复杂的医学信息。为了研究患者对自身病情的了解程度,我们将患者对其动脉瘤相关病史的了解情况与病历中的信息进行了比较。
对神经外科门诊的脑动脉瘤患者进行访谈,询问他们蛛网膜下腔出血病史、动脉瘤数量、动脉瘤治疗情况及治疗结果。研究人员从病历中提取相应数据。我们使用kappa评分来评估患者回答与病历之间的一致性。
178例研究患者中女性占多数(71%),平均年龄为54.4岁。病历显示,56%的患者目前患有未处理的动脉瘤,53%曾经历过蛛网膜下腔出血,29%有多个动脉瘤,68%曾接受过手术或血管内动脉瘤治疗。患者的回答显示,在100例患有未处理动脉瘤的患者中,33%不知道自己患有未处理的动脉瘤。所有患者中有90%知道自己是否经历过蛛网膜下腔出血(kappa = 0.81,几乎完全一致),78%知道自己有多少个动脉瘤(kappa = 0.57,中度一致),92%明白自己是否曾接受过动脉瘤治疗(kappa = 0.82,几乎完全一致)。
大多数脑动脉瘤患者对其动脉瘤相关病史的许多方面有准确的了解。令人担忧的是,患者最常出现错误的是关于未处理动脉瘤的存在情况,而这一问题与治疗决策以及他们未来发生蛛网膜下腔出血、中风和过早死亡的风险最为相关。