Farrugia Maria Elena, Robson Matthew D, Clover Linda, Anslow Phil, Newsom-Davis John, Kennett Robin, Hilton-Jones David, Matthews Paul M, Vincent Angela
Department of Clinical Neurology, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Brain. 2006 Jun;129(Pt 6):1481-92. doi: 10.1093/brain/awl095. Epub 2006 May 3.
A proportion of patients with myasthenia gravis (MG) without acetylcholine receptor (AChR) antibodies have antibodies to muscle-specific kinase (MuSK). MG with MuSK antibodies (MuSK-MG) is often associated with persistent bulbar involvement, including marked facial weakness and tongue muscle wasting. The extent of muscle wasting in MuSK-MG, and whether it is also found in the few acetylcholine receptor (AChR-MG) patients who have persistent bulbar involvement, is not clear. We studied 12 MuSK-MG patients and recruited 14 AChR-MG patients matched broadly for age, sex ratio, duration of disease and degree of ocular, bulbar and facial weakness. We used coronal and sagittal T1-weighted (T1W) and T2-weighted (T2W) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to assess muscle wasting in facial and tongue muscles. Hyperintense signal on T1W MRI and comparison of axial T1W sequences with cUTE sequences were used to assess fibrous/fatty tissue in the tongue. We compared the results with those of four patients with myotonic dystrophy and 12 healthy individuals. We correlated the changes with clinical and treatment histories, and established a new ocular-bulbar-facial-respiratory (OBFR) score. At the time of study, none of the clinical measures, including the OBFR score, differed between the two MG groups. MRI demonstrated thinning of the buccinator, orbicularis oris (O.oris) and orbicularis oculi (O.oculi) muscles in MuSK-MG patients compared with healthy controls, whereas thinning of these muscles was not significant in AChR-MG. Tongue areas with T1W high signal were increased in MuSK-MG patients and the intensity of the signal on axial T1W sequences was greater in MuSK-MG than in controls. To look for possible correlations between imaging and clinical findings, we pooled results from all MG patients. The duration of treatment with prednisolone at >40 mg on alternate days (AD) correlated positively with the percentage of tongue area with high signal (P = 0.006) and negatively with MRI measurements of individual muscles and with the mean muscle dimensions (P = 0.001). The new OBFR score correlated positively with current Myasthenia Gravis Foundation of America grades and with the percentage of high signal (P = 0.004) and negatively with the mean muscle dimensions (P < 0.001). The results show that bulbar and facial muscle weakness and wasting are associated with significant muscle atrophy and fatty replacement in MuSK-MG, which was not found in the AChR-MG patients. MuSK antibodies per se may predispose to muscle thinning, but the difficulties in obtaining clinical remission under steroid therapy in some patients, resulting in long duration of treatment with higher doses (>40 mg AD), may be an additional factor.
一部分无乙酰胆碱受体(AChR)抗体的重症肌无力(MG)患者存在肌肉特异性激酶(MuSK)抗体。伴有MuSK抗体的MG(MuSK - MG)常伴有持续性延髓受累,包括明显的面部无力和舌肌萎缩。MuSK - MG中肌肉萎缩的程度,以及在少数有持续性延髓受累的乙酰胆碱受体(AChR - MG)患者中是否也存在肌肉萎缩,尚不清楚。我们研究了12例MuSK - MG患者,并招募了14例AChR - MG患者,这些患者在年龄、性别比例、病程以及眼肌、延髓肌和面部无力程度方面大致匹配。我们使用冠状位和矢状位T1加权(T1W)及T2加权(T2W)磁共振成像(MRI)来评估面部和舌肌的肌肉萎缩情况。利用T1W MRI上的高信号以及轴向T1W序列与cUTE序列的比较来评估舌部的纤维/脂肪组织。我们将结果与4例强直性肌营养不良患者和12名健康个体的结果进行了比较。我们将这些变化与临床和治疗史相关联,并建立了一个新的眼 - 延髓 - 面部 - 呼吸(OBFR)评分。在研究时,包括OBFR评分在内的所有临床指标在两组MG患者之间并无差异。与健康对照相比,MRI显示MuSK - MG患者的颊肌、口轮匝肌(O.oris)和眼轮匝肌(O.oculi)变薄,而在AChR - MG患者中这些肌肉变薄并不显著。MuSK - MG患者舌部T1W高信号区域增加,且轴向T1W序列上的信号强度在MuSK - MG患者中比在对照组中更大。为了寻找影像学与临床发现之间可能的相关性,我们汇总了所有MG患者的结果。隔日服用泼尼松龙剂量>40 mg的治疗持续时间与舌部高信号区域的百分比呈正相关(P = 0.006),与个体肌肉的MRI测量值以及平均肌肉尺寸呈负相关(P = 0.001)。新的OBFR评分与当前美国重症肌无力基金会分级以及高信号百分比呈正相关(P = 0.004),与平均肌肉尺寸呈负相关(P < 0.001)。结果表明,延髓和面部肌肉无力及萎缩与MuSK - MG中显著的肌肉萎缩和脂肪替代相关,而在AChR - MG患者中未发现这种情况。MuSK抗体本身可能易导致肌肉变薄,但部分患者在类固醇治疗下难以获得临床缓解,从而导致更高剂量(>40 mg隔日)的长期治疗,这可能是另一个因素。