Curtis C F, Lamport A I, Lloyd D H
Dermatology Referral Service, Rooftops, Spring View Road, Ware, Herts, UK.
Vet Dermatol. 2006 Jun;17(3):163-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-3164.2006.00512.x.
A masked, controlled study was designed to investigate the clinical efficacy of a staphylococcal autogenous bacterin for the control of canine idiopathic recurrent pyoderma (IRP). Ten dogs with at least three prior episodes of recurrent superficial pyoderma were recruited. All were screened and found to be free of ectoparasitic and fungal disease and failed to respond favourably to a dietary trial. Those exhibiting signs of pruritus responded completely to antibacterial therapy. Haematological and biochemical parameters were generally unremarkable and all dogs were euthyroid. Staphylococcus intermedius cultures from lesions were used to produce an autogenous bacterin for each animal. A numerical 'lesion score' was allocated and dogs were randomly divided into two groups of five (groups 1 and 2). Both groups received a 4-week course of antibiotic; group 1 also received concurrent s/c injections of bacterin, which continued until week 10. Group 2 received no additional therapy. All dogs were re-examined and rescored at weeks 5 and 10 and repeat blood samples were submitted at week 10 to screen for adverse effects. Comparison of scores at week 0 and week 5 (Mann-Whitney U-test) revealed no significant differences between the groups. At week 10, group 2 (control group) individual lesion scores were significantly higher compared with the group receiving bacterin (P < 0.05) and there was a significantly greater increase in the sum of the individual lesion scores for group 2 compared with group 1, from week 5 to week 10 (P < 0.05). No adverse reactions to bacterin therapy were detected. These results suggest that autogenous bacterins may provide an alternative, safe, effective method for the control of canine IRP. Further studies using larger groups of dogs and for a longer follow-up period are now warranted.
一项设盲对照研究旨在调查葡萄球菌自身菌苗对犬特发性复发性脓皮病(IRP)的临床疗效。招募了10只至少有三次复发性浅表脓皮病发作史的犬。所有犬均经过筛查,发现无体外寄生虫和真菌疾病,且对饮食试验无良好反应。表现出瘙痒症状的犬对抗菌治疗完全有反应。血液学和生化指标一般无异常,所有犬甲状腺功能正常。用病变部位的中间葡萄球菌培养物为每只动物制备自身菌苗。分配了一个数字“病变评分”,并将犬随机分为两组,每组5只(第1组和第2组)。两组均接受为期4周的抗生素疗程;第1组还同时接受皮下注射菌苗,持续至第10周。第2组未接受额外治疗。所有犬在第5周和第10周重新检查并重新评分,并在第10周采集重复血样以筛查不良反应。第0周和第5周评分的比较(Mann-Whitney U检验)显示两组之间无显著差异。在第10周,第2组(对照组)的个体病变评分显著高于接受菌苗治疗的组(P < 0.05),并且从第5周到第10周,第2组个体病变评分总和的增加显著大于第1组(P < 0.05)。未检测到对菌苗治疗的不良反应。这些结果表明,自身菌苗可能为控制犬IRP提供一种替代、安全、有效的方法。现在有必要使用更多犬只并进行更长随访期的进一步研究。