Zhu Xiong-xiang, Hu Da-hai, Chen Bi, Han Jun-tao, Dong Viao-long, Jia Chi-yu, Yao Qing-jun
Department of Burns, Xijing Hospital, The Fourth Military Medical University, Xi'an 710032, PR China.
Zhonghua Shao Shang Za Zhi. 2006 Feb;22(1):19-22.
To explore the better clinical methods for the management of deep facial burn with optimal quality. Methods Fifty-four patients with deep facial burns were enrolled in the study and were divided into delayed skin grafting group (n=48) and early escharectomy group (n=6). In delayed grafting group, after the erosion of new born granulation tissue to the basal layer with blade holder or with peel or eschar shaving method at 3 postburn weeks (PBW) according to the eschar separation and granulation growth status, the whole face of the patients were divided into 10 regions and were then covered by split thickness auto skin. The same treatment was performed on the patients in early escharectomy group at 1 PBW. Physical therapy and plastic surgery were applied after skin grafting, and the patients were followed up from 3 month to 11 years. The first operation time, postburn facial operation time, operation times to repair the whole face, blood content of Hb, the amount of blood transfusion and hemorrhage and the prognosis were compared between the two groups.
There was no difference between the two groups in regards to the first operation time, the total operation times,blood concentration of Hb before and after operation,and the amount of blood transfusion during the operation (P > 0.05). The operation time in delayed grafting group (21.9 +/- 3.2) d was obviously later than that in early escharectomy group (12.6 +/- 1.3) d, (P < 0.05). And there was evidently less amount of hemorrhage during operation(98 +/- 52) ml/100 cm2 than that in early escharectomy group (331 +/- 121) ml/100 cm2 (P < 0.01). The facial appearance of the patients in delayed grafting group was plump with more elasticity and richer expression compared with those in early grafting group. There exhibited different degrees of microstomia and both eyebrow defect in both groups during and after 1 postoperative year. In addition, mild to moderate ectropion and hypertrophic scar on the conjunction of grafted skin could appear in 80% of these patients. These deformities might be corrected by several times of plastic surgery.
Based on the principle of arranging skin grafts according to the cosmetic and functional area units, split thickness skin grafting can provide satisfactory results for the repair of deep burn injury involving whole face when the wounds were treated with eschar peeling, tangential excision, escharectomy, granulation tissue scaling, or early escharectomy. In comparison with early escharectomy, eschar peeling, tangential excision, escharectomy, or granulation tissue scaling can get better results with less bleeding, full and round facial appearance, more elasticity of grafted skin and richer facial expression appearance after the operation. Meanwhile, effective physical therapy and scheduled plastic surgery after skin grafting can also be very important in achieving cosmetic results in the repair and reconstruction of whole facial deep burn.
探讨以最佳质量管理面部深度烧伤的更佳临床方法。方法选取54例面部深度烧伤患者纳入研究,分为延迟植皮组(n = 48)和早期切痂组(n = 6)。延迟植皮组于烧伤后3周(PBW)根据痂皮分离及肉芽生长情况,用持刀片、削痂或切痂法使新生肉芽组织侵蚀至基底层后,将患者全脸分为10个区域,然后覆盖中厚自体皮。早期切痂组患者于1 PBW进行同样处理。植皮后进行物理治疗和整形手术,并对患者进行3个月至11年的随访。比较两组的首次手术时间、烧伤后面部手术时间、修复全脸的手术次数、血红蛋白(Hb)血含量、输血量及出血量以及预后情况。
两组在首次手术时间、总手术次数、手术前后Hb血浓度以及术中输血量方面无差异(P > 0.05)。延迟植皮组的手术时间(21.9±3.2)天明显晚于早期切痂组(12.6±1.3)天(P < 0.05)。且术中出血量(98±52)ml/100 cm²明显少于早期切痂组(331±121)ml/100 cm²(P < 0.01)。延迟植皮组患者的面部外观比早期植皮组丰满,弹性更好,表情更丰富。术后1年期间及之后,两组均出现不同程度的小口畸形和双侧眉缺损。此外,80%的患者在植皮部位结合处可能出现轻至中度睑外翻和增生性瘢痕。这些畸形可通过多次整形手术矫正。
基于按美容和功能区域单位安排植皮的原则,当采用削痂、削切痂、切痂、肉芽组织清理或早期切痂治疗创面时,中厚皮片移植可为全脸深度烧伤的修复提供满意效果。与早期切痂相比,削痂、削切痂、切痂或肉芽组织清理出血更少,术后面部外观丰满圆润,植皮弹性更好,表情更丰富,能取得更好的效果。同时,植皮后有效的物理治疗和定期整形手术对于全脸深度烧伤修复重建的美容效果也非常重要。