McCarty L S, Borgert C J
L.S. McCarty Scientific Research & Consulting, 94 Oakhaven Drive, Markham, Ont., Canada L6C 1X8.
Regul Toxicol Pharmacol. 2006 Jul;45(2):104-18. doi: 10.1016/j.yrtph.2006.03.002. Epub 2006 May 15.
An analysis of current research on mixture toxicity was conducted by critically reviewing published journal articles. The scope was limited to complex mixtures (more than two components) where at least one component was a chlorinated organic chemical. Although the basics of dose-response are widely accepted for mixtures, a number of technical issues, including dose metrics and the unquantified influence of toxicity modifying factors, confound data interpretation and restrict the ability to establish reliable determinations of the presence, nature, and extent of additivity. Lack of knowledge about dose level influences and species-specific variations contribute further interpretational limitations. Within this context, available data indicates that most tested mixtures are near or below simple dose/concentration additivity. Exceptions (both positive and negative) tend to occur when tested mixtures have only a few components or where sensitive whole organism or sub-organismal changes are used as the response metric. Available information does not routinely identify the presence of chlorine as a marker either of a particular type of toxicity or consistently greater potency. The most profound difficulty is the problem of clearly defining when and why similarity and dissimilarity of toxic action is expected for a particular mixture. This impediment largely results from the lack of a generally accepted, technical classification for mode/mechanism of toxic action coupled with the lack of a generally accepted classification scheme for mode/mechanism of toxicity interactions.
通过严格审查已发表的期刊文章,对当前关于混合物毒性的研究进行了分析。范围限于复杂混合物(超过两种成分),其中至少有一种成分是氯化有机化学品。尽管剂量反应的基本原理已被广泛接受用于混合物,但一些技术问题,包括剂量指标以及毒性修饰因子的未量化影响,混淆了数据解释,并限制了确定加和性的存在、性质和程度的可靠判定能力。对剂量水平影响和物种特异性差异的了解不足进一步造成了解释上的限制。在此背景下,现有数据表明,大多数测试混合物接近或低于简单剂量/浓度加和性。当测试混合物只有几种成分,或者使用敏感的整体生物体或亚生物体变化作为反应指标时,往往会出现例外情况(包括正向和负向)。现有信息通常不会将氯的存在确定为特定类型毒性或始终具有更强效力的标志物。最严重的困难是明确界定特定混合物何时以及为何预期毒性作用相似或不同的问题。这一障碍主要源于缺乏一个普遍接受的毒性作用模式/机制技术分类,以及缺乏一个普遍接受的毒性相互作用模式/机制分类方案。