Wilkinson Tim J, Gill Denzil J, Fitzjohn Julie, Palmer Claire L, Mulder Roger T
Christchurch School of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Otago, New Zealand.
Med Teach. 2006 Mar;28(2):129-35. doi: 10.1080/01421590600607195.
This study aimed to determine the consequences for, and coping method used by, medical students who experienced adverse experiences during their training. A nationwide questionnaire based census of all current medical students in New Zealand. The response rate was 83% (1384/1660). Two-thirds of students had at least one adverse experience, with humiliation being the most common and having the greatest adverse impact. Unwanted sexual advances, unfair treatment on the basis of gender or race had a lesser impact for most students. Most students took several hours or several days to get over an adverse episode and most commonly they then avoided that person or department. Around one half sought help. Only one-quarter felt it motivated their learning while one-sixth felt it made them consider leaving medical school. The most common perpetrators were senior doctors or nurses. Unwanted sexual advances were most common from other students or from patients. Humiliation is the experience that affected students the most and had a significant adverse effect on learning. There is a disturbing rate of unacceptable practice within medical schools, not all of which is from doctors.
本研究旨在确定在培训期间经历过不良事件的医学生所面临的后果以及他们所采用的应对方法。对新西兰所有在读医学生进行了一项基于全国范围问卷调查的普查。回复率为83%(1384/1660)。三分之二的学生至少有过一次不良经历,其中羞辱最为常见且产生的负面影响最大。不必要的性侵犯、基于性别或种族的不公平待遇对大多数学生的影响较小。大多数学生需要几个小时或几天时间才能从不良事件中恢复过来,最常见的做法是之后避开那个人或那个部门。大约一半的学生寻求帮助。只有四分之一的学生觉得这对他们的学习有激励作用,而六分之一的学生觉得这让他们考虑离开医学院。最常见的肇事者是资深医生或护士。不必要的性侵犯最常来自其他学生或患者。羞辱是对学生影响最大的经历,对学习有显著的负面影响。医学院内存在令人不安的不可接受行为发生率,而且并非所有行为都来自医生。