Goto Yasunobu, Yamagata Sen
Department of Neurosurgery, Takamatsu Red Cross Hospital, 4-1-3 Ban-cho, Takamatsu, Kagawa 760-0017, Japan.
No Shinkei Geka. 2006 Jun;34(6):577-82.
Although, the overall treatment results in aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) has been improving in recent years, more than 10% of the patients with WFNS grade I and II we have sought to determine the clinical variables for predicting poor functional outcome and symptomatic vasospasm (VS) in patients with individual WFNS grades.
The eligible patient fulfilled the following conditions; (1) ruptured aneurysm located in the anterior part of the circle of Willis, (2) surgically clipped followed by craniotomy under microscope, (3) early surgery within 72 hours, (4) classified to WFNS grade I or II. The medical records were retrospectively reviewed in 119 patients (63 of grade I and 56 of grade II). Sex, age, Fisher's CT group, intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH), site of aneurysm, VS, hydrocephalus, premature bleeding and complications of various kinds were selected as the dependent variables. The contributions of these factors to outcome (Glasgow Outcome Scale, GOS) as well as VS were analyzed using the logistic regression method.
Outcome was better in WFNS grade I (p=0.039), and VS occurred less often and responded well to various interventional techniques and drug delivery. No significant variables contributed to the poor outcome or VS in WFNS grade I. In WFNS grade II, logistic regression analysis showed that VS (OR 34.6, 95% CI, 30.8-38.9, p =0.012) and the complications (OR 52.4, 95% CI, 46.5-59.1, p=0.004) were significant predictors for a poor outcome. Fisher's group 3 was also the only significant factors in VS (OR 3.78, 95% CI, 3.35-4.28, p =0.039). The cause for the difference in outcome and VS were discussed in detail.
The vasospasm and various kinds of complications were the predictive factors of poor clinical outcome, in patient of WFNS garde II. Therefore, careful management and meticulous/pertinent surgical maneuvers are mandatory to obtain better results in aneurysmal SAH, even in better WFNS grades.
尽管近年来动脉瘤性蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)的总体治疗效果有所改善,但仍有超过10%的世界神经外科联盟(WFNS)分级为I级和II级的患者预后不良。我们试图确定个体WFNS分级患者功能预后不良和症状性血管痉挛(VS)的临床变量。
符合条件的患者需满足以下条件:(1)破裂动脉瘤位于 Willis 环前部;(2)接受显微镜下开颅手术夹闭动脉瘤;(3)在72小时内进行早期手术;(4)分级为WFNS I级或II级。对119例患者(I级63例,II级56例)的病历进行回顾性分析。选择性别、年龄、Fisher CT分级、脑室内出血(IVH)、动脉瘤部位、VS、脑积水、过早出血及各种并发症作为因变量。采用逻辑回归方法分析这些因素对预后(格拉斯哥预后评分,GOS)及VS的影响。
WFNS I级患者预后较好(p = 0.039),VS发生率较低,对各种介入技术和药物治疗反应良好。在WFNS I级患者中,没有显著变量与预后不良或VS相关。在WFNS II级患者中,逻辑回归分析显示VS(比值比[OR] 34.6,95%可信区间[CI],30.8 - 38.9,p = 0.012)和并发症(OR 52.4,95% CI,46.5 - 59.1,p = 0.004)是预后不良的显著预测因素。Fisher 3级也是VS的唯一显著因素(OR 3.78,95% CI,3.35 - 4.28,p = 0.039)。详细讨论了预后和VS差异的原因。
血管痉挛和各种并发症是WFNS II级患者临床预后不良的预测因素。因此,即使对于WFNS分级较好的动脉瘤性SAH患者,仔细的管理和精细/恰当的手术操作对于获得更好的治疗结果也是必不可少的。