Thomas Marion
REHSEIS (Laboratoire de recherches épistémologiques et historiques sur les sciences exactes et les institutions scientifiques), CNRS/Université Paris 7-Denis Diderot, 2 place Jussieu, 75251 Paris cedex 05, France.
Stud Hist Philos Biol Biomed Sci. 2006 Jun;37(2):273-94. doi: 10.1016/j.shpsc.2006.03.011. Epub 2006 Jun 5.
Robert Yerkes is a pivotal figure in American psychology and primatology in the first half of the twentieth century. As is well known, Yerkes first studied ape intelligence in 1915, on a visit to the private California laboratory of the psychiatrist Gilbert Hamilton, a former student. Less widely appreciated is how far the work done at the Hamilton lab, in its aims and ambitions as well as its techniques, served as a template for much of Yerkes's research thereafter. This paper uses the Hamilton-Yerkes relationship to re-examine Yerkes's career and, more generally, that of American psychology in the early twentieth century. Three points especially are emphasized: first, the role of Freudian psychoanalysis as a spur to Hamilton's experimental studies of ape intelligence; second, the importance of Hamilton's laboratory, with its semi-wild population of monkeys and ape, as a model for Yerkes's efforts to create a laboratory of his own; and third, the influence on Yerkes of Hamilton's optimism about experimental psychological studies of nonhuman primates as a source of lessons beneficial to a troubled human world.
罗伯特·耶基斯是20世纪上半叶美国心理学和灵长类学领域的关键人物。众所周知,1915年,耶基斯首次对猿类智力展开研究,当时他拜访了身为前学生的精神病学家吉尔伯特·汉密尔顿位于加利福尼亚州的私人实验室。然而,汉密尔顿实验室所开展的工作,在目标、抱负以及技术方面,对耶基斯此后的诸多研究起到了多大程度的模板作用,却鲜为人知。本文借助汉密尔顿与耶基斯的关系,重新审视耶基斯的职业生涯,更广泛地说,是20世纪初美国心理学的发展历程。特别强调三点:其一,弗洛伊德精神分析对汉密尔顿猿类智力实验研究的推动作用;其二,汉密尔顿实验室及其半野生猴群和猿群对于耶基斯创建自己实验室的示范意义;其三,汉密尔顿对非人类灵长类动物实验心理学研究的乐观态度对耶基斯的影响,即此类研究可成为造福陷入困境的人类世界的经验教训来源。