Shafqat S, Khealani B A, Awan F, Abedin S E
Section of Neurology, Department of Medicine, Aga Khan University Medical College, Karachi, Pakistan.
Eur J Neurol. 2006 Jun;13(6):662-5. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-1331.2006.01071.x.
Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) comprises multiple subtypes whose nosological and pathophysiologic interrelationships are unclear. In an attempt to better understand the relationship between the disease's major subtypes, we reviewed the characteristics of GBS cases consecutively admitted to a tertiary care hospital in Karachi, Pakistan, over a 13-year period. Of 175 cases, 80 (46%) were demyelinating and 55 (31%) axonal, whilst 40 (23%) had ambiguous electrophysiological findings precluding classification. The three groups differed in severity of weakness at presentation (axonal approximately ambiguous > demyelinating; P = 0.002 for arm strength and P = 0.025 for leg strength); mean age (demyelinating > axonal > ambiguous; P = 0.05); and mean cerebrospinal fluid protein concentration (demyelinating > ambiguous > axonal; P = 0.05). However, they were similar in several other respects, including gender ratio, proportion of pediatric cases, history of antecedent infection, length of hospital stay, need and duration of mechanical ventilation, and functional outcome at discharge. Stool culture data was available for 146 (83%) cases in the study; none was positive for Campylobacter jejuni. GBS in Pakistan comprises a high proportion of axonal cases. Similarity of outcomes in axonal and demyelinating variants and lack of C. jejuni stool culture positivity are atypical features.
吉兰-巴雷综合征(GBS)包含多种亚型,其疾病分类学和病理生理学的相互关系尚不清楚。为了更好地理解该疾病主要亚型之间的关系,我们回顾了在巴基斯坦卡拉奇一家三级护理医院连续13年收治的GBS病例的特征。175例病例中,80例(46%)为脱髓鞘型,55例(31%)为轴索性,40例(23%)电生理检查结果不明确,无法分类。三组在就诊时的肌无力严重程度(轴索性约不明确型>脱髓鞘型;上肢肌力P = 0.002,下肢肌力P = 0.025)、平均年龄(脱髓鞘型>轴索性>不明确型;P = 0.05)以及平均脑脊液蛋白浓度(脱髓鞘型>不明确型>轴索性;P = 0.05)方面存在差异。然而,在其他几个方面它们是相似的,包括性别比例、儿科病例比例、前驱感染史、住院时间、机械通气的需求和持续时间以及出院时的功能结局。该研究中146例(83%)病例有粪便培养数据;均未检测出空肠弯曲菌阳性。巴基斯坦的GBS病例中轴索性病例占比很高。轴索性和脱髓鞘型变体在结局方面的相似性以及空肠弯曲菌粪便培养阴性是不典型的特征。