Römer Wolfgang, Nömayr Anton, Uder Michael, Bautz Werner, Kuwert Torsten
Clinic of Nuclear Medicine, University of Erlangen-Nuremberg, Erlangen, Germany.
J Nucl Med. 2006 Jul;47(7):1102-6.
Hybrid cameras combining SPECT and spiral CT offer the opportunity to obtain a diagnostic-quality CT image of scintigraphically suggestive lesions that directly correlates with the SPECT image. The field of view of the CT scan can be adapted on the basis of the SPECT findings ("SPECT-guided CT"). The aim of the present study was to investigate the value of SPECT-guided CT in the assessment of foci of increased bone metabolism classified as indeterminate on SPECT.
Of 272 consecutively examined patients with histologically confirmed malignancy who underwent bone scintigraphy, 112 (41%) required further workup by SPECT because a definite diagnosis could not be established using whole-body planar scintigraphy alone. In 57 of these patients, SPECT was accompanied by inline CT over the body region of interest; the remaining 55 subjects underwent only stand-alone SPECT for logistic reasons. The 57 SPECT/CT studies were retrospectively evaluated by readers who were unaware of the clinical pretest probability and the findings on the planar scans. In total, 52 lesions in 44 patients were rated as indeterminate on the SPECT images. Afterwards, the corresponding SPECT/CT images were analyzed and the findings previously rated as indeterminate were classified either as definitely benign, indeterminate, or definitely malignant.
Of the 52 indeterminate findings on SPECT, 33 (63%) could be correlated with benign findings on CT. These findings involved mostly osteochondrosis, spondylosis, and spondylarthrosis of the spine. Fifteen lesions (29%) could be correlated with osteolysis or sclerotic metastases on CT. Even after analysis of the SPECT/CT images, 4 lesions (8%) remained indeterminate. These lesions were in the ribs and the scapula.
SPECT-guided CT was able to clarify more than 90% of SPECT findings classified as indeterminate in an analysis that was masked as to clinical pretest probability and the planar scan findings. Further studies carefully addressing the cost efficiency of this new technology and its actual clinical value are encouraged by this observation.
结合单光子发射计算机断层扫描(SPECT)和螺旋CT的混合相机提供了获得与SPECT图像直接相关的闪烁显像提示性病变的诊断质量CT图像的机会。CT扫描的视野可以根据SPECT的结果进行调整(“SPECT引导的CT”)。本研究的目的是探讨SPECT引导的CT在评估SPECT上分类为不确定的骨代谢增加灶中的价值。
在272例连续接受组织学证实为恶性肿瘤且进行了骨闪烁显像的患者中,112例(41%)因仅使用全身平面闪烁显像无法明确诊断而需要进一步通过SPECT检查。在这些患者中,57例在感兴趣的身体区域进行了SPECT联合在线CT检查;其余55例因后勤原因仅接受了单独的SPECT检查。57例SPECT/CT研究由不了解临床预测试概率和平面扫描结果的读者进行回顾性评估。总共有44例患者的52个病变在SPECT图像上被评为不确定。之后,分析相应的SPECT/CT图像,并将先前评为不确定的结果分类为明确良性、不确定或明确恶性。
在SPECT上的52个不确定结果中,33个(63%)可与CT上的良性结果相关。这些结果主要涉及脊柱的骨软骨病、脊椎关节强硬和脊椎关节炎。15个病变(29%)可与CT上的骨质溶解或硬化性转移相关。即使在分析了SPECT/CT图像后,仍有4个病变(8%)不确定。这些病变位于肋骨和肩胛骨。
在一项对临床预测试概率和平面扫描结果进行盲法分析中,SPECT引导的CT能够明确90%以上分类为不确定的SPECT结果。这一观察结果鼓励进一步开展仔细研究该新技术成本效益及其实际临床价值的研究。