Winston Joel S, O'Doherty John, Kilner James M, Perrett David I, Dolan Raymond J
Wellcome Department of Imaging Neuroscience, University College London, 12 Queen Square, London WC1N 3BG, UK.
Neuropsychologia. 2007 Jan 7;45(1):195-206. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2006.05.009. Epub 2006 Jul 7.
Attractiveness is a facial attribute that shapes human affiliative behaviours. In a previous study we reported a linear response to facial attractiveness in orbitofrontal cortex (OFC), a region involved in reward processing. There are strong theoretical grounds for the hypothesis that coding stimulus reward value also involves the amygdala. The aim of the present investigation is to address whether the amygdala is also sensitive to reward value in faces, indexed as facial attractiveness. We hypothesized that contrary to the linear effects reported previously in OFC, the amygdala would show a non-linear effect of attractiveness by responding to both high and low attractive faces relative to middle attractive faces. Such a non-linear response would explain previous failures to report an amygdala response to attractiveness. Human subjects underwent fMRI while they were presented with faces that varied in facial attractiveness where the task was either to rate faces for facial attractiveness or for age. Consistent with our hypothesis, right amygdala showed a predicted non-linear response profile with greater responses to highly attractive and unattractive faces compared to middle-ranked faces, independent of task. Distinct patterns of activity were seen across different regions of OFC, with some sectors showing linear effects of attractiveness, others exhibiting a non-linear response profile and still others demonstrating activation only during age judgments. Significant effects were also seen in medial prefrontal and paracingulate cortices, posterior OFC, insula, and superior temporal sulcus during explicit attractiveness judgments. The non-linear response profile of the amygdala is consistent with a role in sensing the value of social stimuli, a function that may also involve specific sectors of the OFC.
吸引力是一种塑造人类亲和行为的面部属性。在之前的一项研究中,我们报告了眶额皮质(OFC)对面部吸引力的线性反应,该区域参与奖赏处理。有充分的理论依据支持这样的假设,即对刺激奖赏价值进行编码也涉及杏仁核。本研究的目的是探讨杏仁核是否也对面部中的奖赏价值敏感,该奖赏价值以面部吸引力为指标。我们假设,与之前在OFC中报告的线性效应相反,杏仁核对吸引力会表现出非线性效应,即相对于中等吸引力的面孔,对高吸引力和低吸引力的面孔都会做出反应。这样的非线性反应可以解释之前未能报告杏仁核对吸引力有反应的情况。人类受试者在接受功能磁共振成像(fMRI)时,会看到面部吸引力不同的面孔,任务是对面孔的面部吸引力或年龄进行评分。与我们的假设一致,右侧杏仁核显示出预期的非线性反应模式,与中等排名的面孔相比,对高吸引力和无吸引力的面孔有更强的反应,且与任务无关。在OFC的不同区域观察到了不同的活动模式,一些区域显示出吸引力的线性效应,另一些区域呈现出非线性反应模式,还有一些区域仅在年龄判断时表现出激活。在明确的吸引力判断过程中,内侧前额叶和扣带旁皮质、OFC后部、脑岛和颞上沟也观察到了显著效应。杏仁核的非线性反应模式与感知社会刺激价值的作用一致,这一功能可能也涉及OFC的特定区域。