Nadler Arie, Halabi Samer
Department of Psychology, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.
J Pers Soc Psychol. 2006 Jul;91(1):97-110. doi: 10.1037/0022-3514.91.1.97.
Integrating research on social identity processes and helping relations, the authors proposed that low-status group members who are high identifiers will be unwilling to receive help from the high-status group when status relations are perceived as unstable and help is dependency-oriented. The first experiment, a minimal group experiment, found negative reactions to help from a high-status outgroup when status relations were unstable. The 2nd and 3rd experiments, which used real groups of Israeli Arabs and Israeli Jews, replicated this finding and showed that high identifiers were less receptive to help from the high-status outgroup than low identifiers. The 4th experiment, a help-seeking experiment with real groups of competing high schools, found that the least amount of help was sought from a high-status group by high identifiers when status relations were perceived as unstable and help was dependency-oriented. Theoretical and applied implications are discussed.
综合社会身份过程和帮助关系的研究,作者提出,当地位关系被视为不稳定且帮助以依赖为导向时,具有高度身份认同的低地位群体成员将不愿意接受高地位群体的帮助。第一个实验是一个最小群体实验,发现当地位关系不稳定时,对高地位外群体的帮助会产生负面反应。第二个和第三个实验使用了以色列阿拉伯人和以色列犹太人的真实群体,重复了这一发现,并表明与低身份认同者相比,高身份认同者对高地位外群体的帮助接受度更低。第四个实验是一个针对相互竞争的高中真实群体的求助实验,发现当地位关系被视为不稳定且帮助以依赖为导向时,高身份认同者从高地位群体寻求的帮助最少。文中讨论了理论和应用方面的意义。