Black Jed, Houghton William C
Stanford Sleep Disorders Clinic, CA 94305, USA.
Sleep. 2006 Jul;29(7):939-46. doi: 10.1093/sleep/29.7.939.
To assess the effectiveness of sodium oxybate therapy, modafinil therapy and the combination of the two for excessive daytime sleepiness in narcolepsy patients previously taking modafinil.
Double-blind, placebo-controlled, multicenter study.
Forty-four sites in the United States, Canada, the Czech Republic, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom.
Two hundred seventy- adult patients with narcolepsy taking 200 to 600 mg of modafinil daily for the treatment of excessive daytime sleepiness.
Patients received unchanged doses of modafinil (with sodium-oxybate placebo) during a 2-week baseline phase. Following a baseline polysomnogram and Maintenance of Wakefulness Test, they were randomly assigned to 1 of 4 treatment groups: sodium-oxybate placebo plus modafinil placebo, sodium oxybate plus modafinil placebo, modafinil plus sodium-oxybate placebo, or sodium oxybate plus modafinil. Sodium oxybate was administered as 6 g nightly for 4 weeks and was then increased to 9 g nightly for 4 additional weeks. The primary efficacy measure was the Maintenance of Wakefulness Test; secondary measures included the Epworth Sleepiness Scale, diary recordings, and the Clinical Global Impression-change scale.
Following the switch from modafinil to placebo, the mean average daytime sleep latency on the Maintenance of Wakefulness Test decreased from 9.74 minutes at baseline to 6.87 minutes after 8 weeks (p < .001). In the sodium-oxybate group, there was no decrease in sleep latency, suggesting that this drug was as efficacious in treating the excessive daytime sleepiness as the previously administered modafinil. In contrast, the sodium-oxybate/modafinil group demonstrated an increase in daytime sleep latency from 10.43 minutes to 13.15 minutes (p < .001), suggesting that this combination of drugs produced an additive effect. The sodium-oxybate group also demonstrated a decrease in median average Epworth Sleepiness Scale scores, from 15 to 12.0, whereas the sodium-oxybate/modafinil group decreased from 15.0 to 11.0 (for both, p < .001). The Clinical Global Impression-Change scale demonstrated similar results.
Sodium oxybate and modafinil are both effective for treating excessive daytime sleepiness in narcolepsy, producing additive effects when used together. Sodium oxybate is beneficial as both monotherapy and as adjunctive therapy for the treatment of excessive daytime sleepiness in narcolepsy.
评估羟丁酸钠疗法、莫达非尼疗法以及二者联合疗法对既往服用莫达非尼的发作性睡病患者日间过度嗜睡的疗效。
双盲、安慰剂对照、多中心研究。
美国、加拿大、捷克共和国、法国、德国、荷兰、瑞士和英国的44个研究点。
270名成年发作性睡病患者,他们每天服用200至600毫克莫达非尼以治疗日间过度嗜睡。
在为期2周的基线期,患者继续服用原剂量的莫达非尼(加羟丁酸钠安慰剂)。在进行基线多导睡眠图和清醒维持测试后,他们被随机分配到4个治疗组中的1组:羟丁酸钠安慰剂加莫达非尼安慰剂、羟丁酸钠加莫达非尼安慰剂、莫达非尼加羟丁酸钠安慰剂或羟丁酸钠加莫达非尼。羟丁酸钠每晚服用6克,持续4周,然后增加至每晚9克,再持续4周。主要疗效指标是清醒维持测试;次要指标包括爱泼沃斯嗜睡量表、日记记录和临床总体印象变化量表。
从莫达非尼换为安慰剂后,清醒维持测试中平均日间睡眠潜伏期从基线时的9.74分钟降至8周后的6.87分钟(p <.001)。在羟丁酸钠组,睡眠潜伏期没有下降,这表明该药物在治疗日间过度嗜睡方面与之前服用的莫达非尼疗效相当。相比之下,羟丁酸钠/莫达非尼组的日间睡眠潜伏期从10.43分钟增加到13.15分钟(p <.001),这表明这种药物组合产生了相加效应。羟丁酸钠组的爱泼沃斯嗜睡量表平均得分中位数也从15降至12.0,而羟丁酸钠/莫达非尼组从15.0降至11.0(两者p均<.001)。临床总体印象变化量表显示了类似的结果。
羟丁酸钠和莫达非尼对治疗发作性睡病的日间过度嗜睡均有效,联合使用时会产生相加效应。羟丁酸钠作为单一疗法和辅助疗法对治疗发作性睡病的日间过度嗜睡均有益。