Benli I Teoman, Ates Bülent, Akalin Serdar, Citak Mehmet, Kaya Alper, Alanay Ahmet
Department of Orthopedics and Traumatology, Faculty of Medicine, UFUK University, Mithatpasa Cad. 59/2, Kyzylay, Ankara 06420, Turkey.
Eur Spine J. 2007 Mar;16(3):381-91. doi: 10.1007/s00586-006-0147-3. Epub 2006 Aug 19.
Last two decades witnessed great advances in the surgical treatment of idiopathic scoliosis. However, the number of studies evaluating the long-term results of these treatment methods is relatively low. During recent years, besides radiological and clinical studies, questionnaires like SRS-22 assessing subjective functional and mental status and life-quality of patients have gained importance for the evaluation of these results. In this study, surgical outcome and Turkish SRS-22 questionnaire results of 109 late-onset adolescent idiopathic scoliosis patients surgically treated with third-generation instrumentation [Texas Scottish Rite Hospital (TSRH) System] and followed for a minimum of 10 years were evaluated. The balance was analyzed clinically and radiologically by the measurement of the lateral trunk shift (LT), shift of head (SH), and shift of stable vertebra (SS). Mean age of the patients was 14.4+/-1.9 and mean follow-up period was 136.9+/-12.7 months. When all the patients were included, the preoperative mean Cobb angle of major curves in the frontal plane was 60.8 degrees +/-17.5 degrees . Major curves that were corrected by 38.7+/-22.1% in the bending radiograms, postoperatively achieved a correction of 64.0+/-15.8%. At the last follow-up visit, 10.3 degrees +/-10.8 degrees of correction loss was recorded in major curves in the frontal plane with 50.5+/-23.1% final correction rate. Also, the mean postoperative and final kyphosis angles and lumbar lordosis angles were 37.7 degrees +/-7.4 degrees , 37.0 degrees +/-8.4 degrees , 37.5 degrees +/-8.7 degrees , and 36.3 degrees +/-8.5 degrees , respectively. A statistically significant correction was obtained at the sagittal plane; mean postoperative changes compared to preoperative values were 7.9 degrees and 12.9 degrees for thoracic and lumbar regions, respectively. On the other hand, normal physiological thoracic and lumbar sagittal contours were achieved in 83.5% and 67.9% of the patients, respectively. Postoperatively, a statistically significant correction was obtained in LT, SH, and SS values (P<0.05). Although, none of the patients had completely balanced curves preoperatively, in 95.4% of the patients the curves were found to be completely balanced or clinically well balanced postoperatively. This rate was maintained at the last follow-up visit. Overall, four patients (3.7%) had implant failure. Early superficial infection was observed in three (2.8%) patients. Radiologically presence of significant consolidation, absence of implant failure, and correction loss, and clinical relief of pain were considered as the proof of a posterior solid fusion mass. About ten (9.2%) patients were considered to have pseudoarthrosis: four patients with implant failure and six patients with correction loss over 15 degrees at the frontal plane. About four (3.7%) patients among the first 20 patients had neurological deficit only wake-up test was used for neurological monitoring of these patients. No neurological deficit was observed in the 89 patients for whom intraoperative neurological monitoring with SSEP and TkMMEP was performed. Overall, average scores of SRS-22 questionnaire for general self-image, function, mental status, pain, and satisfaction from treatment were 3.8+/-0.7, 3.6+/-0.7, 4.0+/-0.8, 3.6+/-0.8, and 4.6+/-0.3, respectively at the last follow-up visit. Results of about 10 years of follow-up these patients treated with TSRH instrumentation suggest that the method is efficient for the correction of frontal and sagittal plane deformities and trunk balance. In addition, it results in a better life-quality.
过去二十年见证了特发性脊柱侧凸外科治疗的巨大进展。然而,评估这些治疗方法长期结果的研究数量相对较少。近年来,除了放射学和临床研究外,像SRS-22这样评估患者主观功能、心理状态和生活质量的问卷在评估这些结果方面变得越来越重要。在本研究中,对109例晚发性青少年特发性脊柱侧凸患者进行了评估,这些患者采用第三代器械(德克萨斯苏格兰礼医院(TSRH)系统)进行手术治疗,并至少随访了10年。通过测量侧方躯干偏移(LT)、头部偏移(SH)和稳定椎体偏移(SS),从临床和放射学角度分析平衡情况。患者的平均年龄为14.4±1.9岁,平均随访期为136.9±12.7个月。纳入所有患者时,额状面主要弯术前平均Cobb角为60.8°±17.5°。在弯曲位X线片上矫正了38.7±22.1%的主要弯,术后达到了64.0±15.8%的矫正。在最后一次随访时,额状面主要弯记录到10.3°±10.8°的矫正丢失,最终矫正率为50.5±23.1%。此外,术后和最终的平均后凸角和腰椎前凸角分别为37.7°±7.4°、37.0°±8.4°、37.5°±8.7°和36.3°±8.5°。在矢状面获得了统计学上显著的矫正;与术前值相比,胸段和腰段术后平均变化分别为7.9°和12.9°。另一方面,分别有83.5%和67.9%的患者获得了正常的生理性胸段和腰段矢状轮廓。术后,LT、SH和SS值获得了统计学上显著的矫正(P<0.05)。虽然术前没有患者的曲线完全平衡,但95.4%的患者术后曲线被发现完全平衡或临床良好平衡。在最后一次随访时这一比例保持不变。总体而言,4例患者(3.7%)出现内固定失败。3例(2.8%)患者发生早期浅表感染。放射学上有明显骨融合、无内固定失败和矫正丢失以及临床疼痛缓解被视为后方坚实融合块的证据。约10例(9.2%)患者被认为有假关节形成:4例内固定失败患者和6例额状面矫正丢失超过15°的患者。前20例患者中有4例(3.7%)仅在唤醒试验用于神经监测时有神经功能缺损。对89例术中采用SSEP和TkMMEP进行神经监测的患者未观察到神经功能缺损。总体而言,在最后一次随访时,SRS-22问卷关于总体自我形象、功能、心理状态、疼痛和治疗满意度的平均得分分别为3.8±0.7、3.6±0.7、4.0±0.8、3.6±0.8和4.6±0.3。对这些采用TSRH器械治疗的患者约10年的随访结果表明,该方法在矫正额状面和矢状面畸形以及躯干平衡方面是有效的。此外,它能带来更好的生活质量。