Norcini John, Anderson M Brownell, McKinley Danette W
Foundation for Advancement of International Medical Education, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA.
Surgery. 2006 Sep;140(3):338-46. doi: 10.1016/j.surg.2006.06.001. Epub 2006 Jul 28.
Graduates of international medical schools (IMGs) make up approximately one quarter of the physician workforce in the United States. Among IMGs are a number of US citizens (USIMGs) who take graduate training positions and ultimately practice in the United States. Compared with graduates of US medical schools (USMGs), relatively little is known about the undergraduate educational experiences of these US citizens. The objective of this study was to identify the schools that produce the most USIMGs and to describe the educational experiences and examination performance of graduates of these schools.
The 10 largest schools were identified based on the number of USIMGs who were certified by the Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates between 2001 and 2004. Information about the institutions was collected from the International Medical Education Directory; educational experience information was gathered from 100 randomly selected transcripts and from a survey that was completed by 418 graduates of the schools. These data were compared with information about USMGs from the curriculum management and information tool and the graduation questionnaire of the Association of American Medical Colleges. Performance on steps 1 and 2CK of the United States Medical Licensing Examination were also analyzed.
Some differences existed between USIMGs and USMGs in the required clinical clerkships, the sites where educational experiences occurred, and the special topics that were covered. USMGs and non-US citizen IMGs had better examination scores than USIMGs.
There are many similarities; however, there are some noteworthy differences between the educational experiences of USIMGs and USMGs. Further work is needed to better understand the educational experiences of USIMGs, particularly in the clinical clerkships.
国际医学院校毕业生(IMGs)约占美国医师劳动力的四分之一。其中有许多美国公民(USIMGs),他们接受研究生培训职位并最终在美国执业。与美国医学院校(USMGs)的毕业生相比,对于这些美国公民的本科教育经历了解相对较少。本研究的目的是确定培养最多USIMGs的学校,并描述这些学校毕业生的教育经历和考试成绩。
根据2001年至2004年间经外国医学毕业生教育委员会认证的USIMGs数量,确定了10所规模最大的学校。从《国际医学教育目录》收集有关这些机构的信息;从100份随机抽取的成绩单以及这些学校418名毕业生完成的一项调查中收集教育经历信息。将这些数据与来自美国医学院协会课程管理和信息工具以及毕业调查问卷中有关USMGs的信息进行比较。还分析了美国医师执照考试第1步和第2步临床知识考试的成绩。
USIMGs和USMGs在必修临床实习、教育经历发生的地点以及涵盖的专题方面存在一些差异。USMGs和非美国公民IMGs的考试成绩优于USIMGs。
存在许多相似之处;然而,USIMGs和USMGs的教育经历之间存在一些值得注意的差异。需要进一步开展工作,以更好地了解USIMGs的教育经历,尤其是在临床实习方面。