Mayo-Smith Michael F, Agrawal Abha
Primary Care Service Line, VA New England Healthcare System, Bedford, MA, USA.
Int J Med Inform. 2007 Oct;76(10):710-6. doi: 10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2006.07.003. Epub 2006 Aug 28.
To analyze the relationship of completion rates for a standardized set of computerized clinical reminders across a large healthcare system to practice and provider characteristics.
The relationship between completion rate for 13 standardized reminders at 49 primary care practices in the VA New England Healthcare System for a 30-day period and practice characteristics, provider demographics and, via survey, provider attitudes was analyzed.
There was no difference in clinical reminder completion rate between staff physicians versus nurse practitioners/physician assistants (87.6% versus 88.1%) but both were better than residents (76.6%, p<0.0001). With residents excluded, there were no differences between hospital and community-based clinics or between teaching and non-teaching sites. Clinical reminder completion rate was lower for sites that did not fully utilize support staff in completion process versus sites that did (82.4% versus 88.1%, p<0.0001). Analysis of survey results showed no correlation of completion rate with provider demographics or attitudes towards reminders. However there was significant correlation with frequency of receiving individual feedback on reminder completion (r=0.288, p=0.004).
Completion of computerized clinical reminders was not affected by a variety of provider characteristics, including professional training, demographics and provider attitude, although was lower among residents than staff providers. However incorporation of support staff into clinic processes and individualized feedback to providers were strongly associated with improved completion. These findings demonstrate the importance of considering practice and provider factors and not just technical elements when implementing informatics tools.
分析在一个大型医疗系统中,一套标准化的计算机化临床提醒的完成率与医疗实践及医疗服务提供者特征之间的关系。
分析了退伍军人事务部新英格兰医疗系统中49家初级保健机构在30天内13项标准化提醒的完成率与医疗实践特征、医疗服务提供者人口统计学信息以及通过调查得出的医疗服务提供者态度之间的关系。
在职医生与执业护士/医师助理之间的临床提醒完成率无差异(分别为87.6%和88.1%),但两者均高于住院医师(76.6%,p<0.0001)。排除住院医师后,医院诊所和社区诊所之间或教学机构与非教学机构之间没有差异。在完成过程中未充分利用辅助人员的机构的临床提醒完成率低于充分利用辅助人员的机构(分别为82.4%和88.1%,p<0.0001)。对调查结果的分析表明,完成率与医疗服务提供者的人口统计学信息或对提醒的态度无关。然而,与收到关于提醒完成情况的个人反馈的频率存在显著相关性(r=0.288,p=0.004)。
计算机化临床提醒的完成情况不受多种医疗服务提供者特征的影响,包括专业培训、人口统计学信息和医疗服务提供者态度,尽管住院医师的完成率低于在职医疗服务提供者。然而,将辅助人员纳入诊所流程以及向医疗服务提供者提供个性化反馈与完成率的提高密切相关。这些发现表明,在实施信息学工具时,考虑医疗实践和医疗服务提供者因素而非仅仅技术因素非常重要。