Doescher Jason S, deGrauw Ton J, Musick Beverly S, Dunn David W, Kalnin Andrew J, Egelhoff John C, Byars Anna Weber, Mathews Vincent P, Austin Joan K
Minnesota Epilepsy Group, St. Paul, MN, USA.
J Child Neurol. 2006 Jun;21(6):491-5.
In the initial assessment of children with new-onset seizures, the suggestion that electroencephalography (EEG) should be standard and that magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) should be optional has been questioned. The purposes of this study were to (1) describe the frequency of EEG and MRI abnormalities and (2) explore relationships between MRI and EEG findings to determine their relevance in the assessment of children with new-onset seizures who are otherwise developing normally. As part of an ongoing, prospective study of children with new-onset seizures, we studied 181 children (90 girls and 91 boys). Children were entered into the study within 3 months of their first-recognized seizure. The association between EEG and MRI abnormalities was explored using a chi-square test. Abnormal MRI findings were found in 32.6% (n = 59) of the sample. The EEG and MRI results agreed with respect to classification into normal or abnormal in 37% (n = 67). Of the 50 children with a normal EEG, however, 21 (42%) were found to have an abnormal MRI. We found an unexpectedly high frequency of imaging abnormalities in our sample of otherwise normal children, although the significance of these findings is not clear. Follow-up of these patients will help us interpret the importance of the abnormalities. Despite our relatively small sample, however, our findings indicate that a normal EEG does not reliably predict a normal MRI in children with first seizures.
在对新发癫痫患儿的初步评估中,关于脑电图(EEG)应作为标准检查且磁共振成像(MRI)应为可选检查的建议受到了质疑。本研究的目的是:(1)描述EEG和MRI异常的发生率;(2)探讨MRI与EEG检查结果之间的关系,以确定它们在评估发育正常的新发癫痫患儿中的相关性。作为一项正在进行的关于新发癫痫患儿的前瞻性研究的一部分,我们对181名儿童(90名女孩和91名男孩)进行了研究。患儿在首次被识别出癫痫发作后的3个月内纳入研究。使用卡方检验探讨EEG与MRI异常之间的关联。在样本中,32.6%(n = 59)的患儿MRI检查结果异常。EEG和MRI结果在正常或异常分类方面的一致性为37%(n = 67)。然而,在EEG正常的50名患儿中,有21名(42%)MRI检查结果异常。我们发现,在我们这个其他方面均正常的患儿样本中,影像学异常的发生率出乎意料地高,尽管这些发现的意义尚不清楚。对这些患者的随访将有助于我们解读这些异常情况的重要性。然而,尽管我们的样本相对较小,但我们的研究结果表明,首次发作患儿的EEG正常并不能可靠地预测其MRI检查结果正常。