Larsen T, Kumar S, Grimmer K, Potter A, Farquharson T, Sharpe P
The Centre for Allied Health Evidence, University of South Australia, City East Campus, North Tce, Adelaide 5000, Australia.
J Sci Med Sport. 2007 Feb;10(1):11-26. doi: 10.1016/j.jsams.2006.07.008. Epub 2006 Sep 6.
This paper presents the findings of a systematic review of guidelines on preventing heat illness in sports participants and officials. University library databases and Internet sources were searched for guidelines pertaining to community-based sports, and occupational health and safety, using a comprehensive list of search terms. Guidelines were included if they met the criteria of English language, full text and fully referenced, and dealt specifically with, or could be extrapolated to, prevention of heat illness in sports participants and officials. Guideline inclusion was evaluated by two independent reviewers, who also independently assessed guideline quality using the AGREE instrument. Common guideline themes were identified by synthesis and recommendations for each theme were extracted. A synthesis of recommendations for common themes was then undertaken. Thirteen eligible guidelines were included. Thirty-two guidelines were excluded, as they did not provide sufficient information on construction or references. The methodological quality of the included guidelines was variable. The evidence-base of the guidelines varied, reflecting primary and secondary research. While five common heat-illness prevention themes were identified (fluid intake, heat limits, clothing, acclimatisation, precautionary interventions), variable recommendations were made pertaining to these themes. This potentially reflected the variable underpinning evidence of the guidelines. This review highlighted the need for better quality guideline construction related to defensible and transparent evidence sources regarding sports participation in hot weather. The synthesised recommendations cautiously provide a framework of current best evidence upon which sporting organisations internationally can base strategies for safe participation in the heat.
本文介绍了一项关于预防运动员和官员中暑指南的系统评价结果。利用一份全面的搜索词清单,在大学图书馆数据库和互联网资源中搜索与社区体育以及职业健康与安全相关的指南。如果指南符合英文、全文且有完整参考文献的标准,并且专门涉及或可外推至预防运动员和官员中暑的内容,则将其纳入。由两名独立评审员评估指南的纳入情况,他们还使用AGREE工具独立评估指南质量。通过综合确定常见的指南主题,并提取每个主题的建议。然后对常见主题的建议进行综合。共纳入13项符合条件的指南。32项指南被排除,因为它们没有提供关于构建或参考文献的足够信息。纳入指南的方法学质量参差不齐。指南的证据基础各不相同,反映了一级和二级研究。虽然确定了五个常见的中暑预防主题(液体摄入、热极限、服装、适应环境、预防干预措施),但针对这些主题的建议各不相同。这可能反映了指南所依据的证据各不相同。本评价强调需要更好地构建指南质量,使其基于关于在炎热天气下参与体育活动的可靠和透明的证据来源。综合建议谨慎地提供了一个当前最佳证据框架,国际体育组织可据此制定在炎热环境下安全参与体育活动的策略。