Yang Chih-Hsun, Hsu Hsiu-Cheng, Shen Su-Chin, Juan Wei-Hsin, Hong Hong-Shang, Chen Chien-Hsun
Department of Dermatology, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan.
Dermatol Surg. 2006 Sep;32(9):1119-22; discussion 1123. doi: 10.1111/j.1524-4725.2006.32254.x.
Tumescent local anesthesia is widely used in dermatologic surgery. Minimizing pain associated with injections is crucial to successful surgical procedures.
This study investigates the pain associated with warm and room temperatures in neutralized or nonneutralized tumescent anesthetic solutions injection.
Thirty-six patients with axilla osmidrosis who underwent local anesthesia for surgery were randomly assigned to three groups. Group A received warm neutral (40 degrees C) and room-temperature neutral (22 degrees C) tumescent injections to each axillary region. Group B received warm neutral (pH 7.35) and warm nonneutral (pH 4.78) tumescent injections on each side of axilla. Group C received warm nonneutral and room-temperature nonneutral tumescent injections on each side of axilla. Pain associated with infiltration of anesthesia was rated on a visual analog scale (VAS).
A statistically significant decrease (p < .001) in pain sensation was reported on the warm, neutral injection side (mean rating, 32.7 mm) compared with the room-temperature, neutral injection side (mean rating, 53.3 mm). Patient-reported pain intensity was significantly lower on the side that received warm, neutral tumescent anesthesia (mean rating, 26.8 mm) than on the side receiving warm, nonneutral tumescent anesthesia (mean rating, 44.9 mm; p < .001). The difference in VAS scores between warm neutral (mean rating, 23.9 mm) and room-temperature nonneutral (mean rating, 61.2 mm) was statistically significant (p < .001).
The warm, neutral tumescent anesthetic preparation effectively suppressed patient pain during dermatologic surgical procedures.
肿胀局麻在皮肤科手术中广泛应用。将注射相关疼痛降至最低对手术成功至关重要。
本研究调查在注射中和或未中和的肿胀麻醉溶液时,与温热及室温相关的疼痛情况。
36例因腋臭接受局部麻醉手术的患者被随机分为三组。A组在每个腋窝区域接受温热中性(40摄氏度)和室温中性(22摄氏度)肿胀注射。B组在腋窝两侧分别接受温热中性(pH 7.35)和温热非中性(pH 4.78)肿胀注射。C组在腋窝两侧分别接受温热非中性和室温非中性肿胀注射。采用视觉模拟评分法(VAS)对麻醉浸润相关疼痛进行评分。
与室温中性注射侧(平均评分53.3毫米)相比,温热中性注射侧(平均评分32.7毫米)的疼痛感觉有统计学显著降低(p <.001)。患者报告的疼痛强度在接受温热中性肿胀麻醉的一侧(平均评分26.8毫米)显著低于接受温热非中性肿胀麻醉的一侧(平均评分44.9毫米;p <.001)。温热中性(平均评分23.9毫米)和室温非中性(平均评分61.2毫米)之间的VAS评分差异有统计学意义(p <.001)。
温热中性肿胀麻醉制剂在皮肤科手术过程中有效抑制了患者的疼痛。