Valero-Cabré Antoni, Payne Bertram R, Pascual-Leone Alvaro
Laboratory of Cerebral Dynamics, Plasticity and Rehabilitation, Department of Anatomy and Neurobiology, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA 02118, USA.
Exp Brain Res. 2007 Feb;176(4):603-15. doi: 10.1007/s00221-006-0639-8. Epub 2006 Sep 14.
Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) appears capable of modulating human cortical excitability beyond the duration of the stimulation train. However, the basis and extent of this "off-line" modulation remains unknown. In a group of anesthetized cats, we applied patterns of real or sham focal rTMS to the visuo-parietal cortex (VP) at high (HF) or low (LF) frequency and recorded brain glucose uptake during (on-line), immediately after (off-line), or 1 h after (late) stimulation. During the on-line period LF and HF rTMS induced a significant relative reduction of (14)C-2DG uptake in the stimulated VP cortex and tightly linked cortical and subcortical structures (e.g. the superficial superior colliculus, the pulvinar, and the LPl nucleus) with respect to homologue areas in the unstimulated hemisphere. During the off-line period HF rTMS induced a significant relative increase in (14)C-2DG uptake in the targeted VP cortex, whereas LF rTMS generated the opposite effect, with only mild network impact. Moderate distributed effects were only recorded after LF rTMS in the posterior thalamic structures. No long lasting cortical or subcortical effects were detected during the late period. Our findings demonstrate opposite modulation of rTMS on local and distant effects along a specific network, depending on the pattern of stimulation. Such effects are demonstrated in the anesthetized animal, ruling out behavioral and non-specific reasons for the differential impact of the stimulation. The findings are consistent with previous differential electrophysiological and behavioral effects of low and high frequency rTMS patterns and provide support to uses of rTMS in neuromodulation.
重复经颅磁刺激(rTMS)似乎能够在刺激序列结束后调节人类皮层兴奋性。然而,这种“离线”调节的基础和程度仍不清楚。在一组麻醉猫中,我们以高频(HF)或低频(LF)模式对视觉顶叶皮层(VP)施加真实或伪聚焦rTMS,并在刺激期间(在线)、刺激后立即(离线)或刺激后1小时(晚期)记录脑葡萄糖摄取。在在线期间,LF和HF rTMS导致受刺激的VP皮层以及与未受刺激半球的同源区域紧密相连的皮层和皮层下结构(如浅层上丘、丘脑枕和外侧后核)中(14)C-2DG摄取显著相对减少。在离线期间,HF rTMS导致目标VP皮层中(14)C-2DG摄取显著相对增加,而LF rTMS产生相反的效果,仅产生轻微的网络影响。仅在LF rTMS后在丘脑后部结构中记录到中度的分布效应。在晚期未检测到持久的皮层或皮层下效应。我们的研究结果表明,根据刺激模式,rTMS对特定网络中的局部和远处效应具有相反的调节作用。这种效应在麻醉动物中得到证实,排除了刺激差异影响的行为和非特异性原因。这些发现与先前低频和高频rTMS模式的不同电生理和行为效应一致,并为rTMS在神经调节中的应用提供了支持。