Pickhardt Perry J, Taylor Andrew J, Kim David H, Reichelderfer Mark, Gopal Deepak V, Pfau Patrick R
Department of Radiology and Section of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, University of Wisconsin Medical School, E3/311 Clinical Science Center, 600 Highland Ave, Madison, WI 53792-3252, USA.
Radiology. 2006 Nov;241(2):417-25. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2412052007. Epub 2006 Sep 18.
To evaluate our experience in the 1st year of computed tomographic (CT) colonography screening since the initiation of local third-party payer coverage.
This HIPAA-compliant study was approved by the institutional review board, and informed consent was waived. Over a 1-year period that ended on April 27, 2005, 1110 consecutive adults (585 women, 525 men; mean age, 58.1 years) underwent primary CT colonography screening. More than 99% were covered by managed care agreements. CT colonographic interpretation was performed with primary three-dimensional polyp detection, and the final results were issued within 2 hours. Patients with large (> or =10-mm) polyps were referred for same-day optical colonoscopy, and patients with medium-sized (6-9-mm) lesions had the option of immediate optical colonoscopy or short-term CT colonography surveillance.
Large colorectal polyps were identified at CT colonography in 43 (3.9%) of 1110 patients. Medium-sized lesions were identified in 77 (6.9%) patients, 31 (40%) of whom chose optical colonoscopy and 46 (60%) of whom chose CT colonography surveillance. Concordant lesions were identified in 65 of 71 patients who underwent subsequent optical colonoscopy (positive predictive value, 91.5%). Sixty-one (86%) of 71 optical colonoscopic procedures were performed on the same day as CT colonography, thereby avoiding the need for repeat bowel preparation. The actual endoscopic referral rate for positive findings at CT colonography was 6.4% (71 of 1110 patients). The demand for CT colonography screening from primary care physicians and their patients increased throughout the study period.
As a primary colorectal screening tool, CT colonography covered by third-party payers has an acceptably low endoscopic referral rate and a high concordance of positive findings at optical colonoscopy.
评估自当地第三方支付者承保以来,计算机断层扫描(CT)结肠成像筛查第一年的经验。
本符合健康保险流通与责任法案(HIPAA)的研究经机构审查委员会批准,且无需知情同意。在截至2005年4月27日的1年期间,1110名连续的成年人(585名女性,525名男性;平均年龄58.1岁)接受了初次CT结肠成像筛查。超过99%的人由管理式医疗协议承保。采用原发性三维息肉检测进行CT结肠成像解读,最终结果在2小时内出具。患有大的(≥10毫米)息肉的患者被转诊进行当日光学结肠镜检查,患有中等大小(6 - 9毫米)病变的患者可选择立即进行光学结肠镜检查或短期CT结肠成像监测。
在1110名患者中,有43名(3.9%)在CT结肠成像中发现了大的结直肠息肉。77名(6.9%)患者发现了中等大小的病变,其中31名(40%)选择了光学结肠镜检查,46名(60%)选择了CT结肠成像监测。在71名接受后续光学结肠镜检查的患者中,有65名发现了一致的病变(阳性预测值为91.5%)。71例光学结肠镜检查中有61例(86%)与CT结肠成像在同一天进行,从而避免了重复肠道准备的需要。CT结肠成像阳性结果的实际内镜转诊率为6.4%(1110名患者中的71名)。在整个研究期间,初级保健医生及其患者对CT结肠成像筛查的需求增加。
作为一种原发性结直肠癌筛查工具,由第三方支付者承保的CT结肠成像具有可接受的低内镜转诊率,且在光学结肠镜检查中阳性结果的一致性较高。