Ghaleb Maisoon Abdullah, Barber Nick, Franklin Bryony D, Yeung Vincent W S, Khaki Zahra F, Wong Ian C K
Centre for Paediatric Pharmacy Research, The School of Pharmacy, University of London, London, England.
Ann Pharmacother. 2006 Oct;40(10):1766-76. doi: 10.1345/aph.1G717. Epub 2006 Sep 19.
To systematically locate and review studies that have investigated the incidence of medication errors (MEs) in pediatric inpatients and identify common errors.
A systematic search of studies related to MEs in children was performed using the following databases: MEDLINE (1951-April 2006), EMBASE (1966-April 2006), Pharm-line (1978-April 2006), International Pharmaceutical Abstracts (1970-April 2006), Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (1982-April 2006), and British Nursing Index (1994-April 2006). Studies of the incidence and nature of MEs in pediatrics were included. The title, abstract, or full article was reviewed for relevance; any study not related to MEs in children was excluded.
Three methods were used to detect MEs in the studies reviewed: spontaneous reporting (n = 10), medication order or chart review (n = 14), or observation (n = 8). There was great variation in the definitions of ME used and the error rates reported. The most common type of ME was dosing error, often involving 10 times the actual dose required. Antibiotics and sedatives were the most common classes of drugs associated with MEs; these are probably among the most common drugs prescribed.
Interpretation of the literature was hindered by variation in definitions employed by different researchers, varying research methods and setting, and a lack of theory-based research. Overall, it would appear that our initial concern about MEs in pediatrics has been validated; however, we do not know the actual size of the problem. Further work to determine the incidence and causes of MEs in pediatrics is urgently needed, as well as evaluation of the best interventions to reduce them.
系统查找并综述调查儿科住院患者用药错误(MEs)发生率的研究,识别常见错误。
使用以下数据库对与儿童MEs相关的研究进行系统检索:医学索引数据库(MEDLINE,1951年 - 2006年4月)、荷兰医学文摘数据库(EMBASE,1966年 - 2006年4月)、药学在线数据库(Pharm-line,1978年 - 2006年4月)、国际药学文摘数据库(International Pharmaceutical Abstracts,1970年 - 2006年4月)、护理学与健康相关文献累积索引数据库(Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature,1982年 - 2006年4月)以及英国护理索引数据库(British Nursing Index,1994年 - 2006年4月)。纳入有关儿科MEs发生率及性质的研究。对标题、摘要或全文进行相关性审查;排除任何与儿童MEs无关的研究。
在所综述的研究中,使用了三种方法来检测MEs:自发报告(n = 10)、医嘱或病历审查(n = 14)或观察(n = 8)。所使用的ME定义和报告的错误率差异很大。最常见的ME类型是剂量错误,通常涉及所需实际剂量的10倍。抗生素和镇静剂是与MEs相关的最常见药物类别;这些可能是最常用的处方药。
不同研究者采用的定义不同、研究方法和背景各异以及缺乏基于理论的研究,阻碍了对文献的解读。总体而言,我们最初对儿科MEs的担忧似乎已得到证实;然而,我们并不清楚问题的实际规模。迫切需要进一步开展工作以确定儿科MEs的发生率和原因,以及评估减少这些错误的最佳干预措施。