Braun Stuart V, Hedden Douglas M, Howard Andrew W
Department of Orthopaedics, Floating Hospital for Children, Tufts-New England Medical Center, 750 Washington Street, #206, Boston, MA 02111, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2006 Oct;88(10):2252-7. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.E.00348.
Superior mesenteric artery syndrome is a known complication associated with the correction of spinal deformity. Recent investigations of this disorder have focused on patient height and weight. We are not aware of any published study examining the degree of deformity, type of curve, or magnitude of correction, and to our knowledge all of the reported literature on this syndrome lacks control data. The purpose of this study was to examine the relationship between the correction of spinal deformity and the development of superior mesenteric artery syndrome in patients with scoliosis. Our hypothesis was that greater correction of spinal deformity would increase the risk of the development of superior mesenteric artery syndrome.
A case-control study was performed over a five-year period. The primary outcome measure was the development of superior mesenteric artery syndrome. The predictor variables that were considered included demographic characteristics; preoperative height, weight, and body mass index; aspects of the deformity, including curve magnitude, Lenke curve classification, and correction; and operative factors, including surgical approach, estimated blood loss, and the presence of operative hypotension.
A review of the records on 364 surgical procedures for scoliosis identified seventeen cases of superior mesenteric artery syndrome. Thirty-four subjects who had had surgery for scoliosis but no superior mesenteric artery syndrome were randomly selected as controls. Eight of the seventeen subjects with superior mesenteric artery syndrome had undergone a two-stage procedure (compared with one of the thirty-four controls, p < 0.001), nine of the seventeen had had combined anterior and posterior procedures (compared with two of the thirty-four controls, p < 0.001), and seven of the seventeen had had a thoracoplasty (compared with two of the thirty-four controls, p < 0.001). No significant differences were noted between the groups with regard to demographic factors. Compared with the controls, the patients in whom superior mesenteric artery syndrome developed were shorter (by a mean of 7.1 cm, p = 0.03), weighed less (by a mean of 11.5 kg, p = 0.001), had a lower body mass index (p = 0.003), had a greater minimal thoracic curve magnitude achieved by bending (a mean of 12 degrees greater [45 degrees for subjects with superior mesenteric artery syndrome and 33 degrees for controls], p = 0.015), had a lower percent correction of the thoracic curve on bending (a mean of 11% lower, p = 0.025), and had more lumbar lateralization (88%, compared with 61% in the control group, had a Lenke lumbar modifier of B or C instead of A, p = 0.008). Multivariate logistic regression analysis identified a staged procedure (odds ratio, 31.0), the lumbar modifier (odds ratio, 9.06), body mass index (odds ratio, 7.75), and thoracic stiffness (odds ratio, 6.67) as the most predictive of the development of superior mesenteric artery syndrome.
Preoperative identification of the risk factors described above in conjunction with preoperative nutritional maximization should be considered in order to limit the prevalence of superior mesenteric artery syndrome in patients undergoing surgical correction of spinal deformity.
肠系膜上动脉综合征是脊柱畸形矫正术后一种已知的并发症。近期对该病症的研究主要集中在患者的身高和体重方面。我们尚未发现有任何已发表的研究探讨畸形程度、侧弯类型或矫正幅度,并且据我们所知,所有关于该综合征的报道文献均缺乏对照数据。本研究的目的是探讨脊柱畸形矫正与脊柱侧弯患者肠系膜上动脉综合征发生之间的关系。我们的假设是,脊柱畸形矫正程度越大,肠系膜上动脉综合征发生的风险越高。
进行了一项为期五年的病例对照研究。主要观察指标是肠系膜上动脉综合征的发生情况。所考虑的预测变量包括人口统计学特征;术前身高、体重和体重指数;畸形的各个方面,包括侧弯幅度、Lenke 侧弯分类和矫正情况;以及手术因素,包括手术方式、估计失血量和术中低血压情况。
回顾 364 例脊柱侧弯手术记录,发现 17 例肠系膜上动脉综合征病例。随机选取 34 例接受脊柱侧弯手术但未发生肠系膜上动脉综合征的患者作为对照。17 例肠系膜上动脉综合征患者中有 8 例接受了两阶段手术(与 34 例对照中的 1 例相比,p < 0.001),17 例中有 9 例接受了前后联合手术(与 34 例对照中的 2 例相比,p < 0.001),17 例中有 7 例接受了胸廓成形术(与 34 例对照中的 2 例相比,p < 0.001)。两组在人口统计学因素方面未发现显著差异。与对照组相比,发生肠系膜上动脉综合征的患者更矮(平均矮 7.1 cm,p = 0.03),体重更轻(平均轻 11.5 kg,p = 0.001),体重指数更低(p = 0.003),侧弯时达到的最小胸弯幅度更大(平均大 12 度[肠系膜上动脉综合征患者为 45 度,对照组为 33 度],p = 0.015),侧弯时胸弯的矫正百分比更低(平均低 11%,p = 0.025),并且腰椎侧凸更明显(88%的患者 Lenke 腰椎修正型为 B 或 C 而非 A,对照组为 61%,p = 0.008)。多因素逻辑回归分析确定,两阶段手术(比值比,31.0)、腰椎修正型(比值比,9.06)、体重指数(比值比,7.75)和胸段僵硬程度(比值比,6.67)是肠系膜上动脉综合征发生的最具预测性因素。
为了降低脊柱畸形手术矫正患者肠系膜上动脉综合征的发生率,应考虑术前识别上述危险因素并同时使术前营养状况达到最佳。