Croff Allen G
Health Phys. 2006 Nov;91(5):449-60. doi: 10.1097/01.HP.0000232853.62454.94.
Radioactive waste classification systems have been developed to allow wastes having similar hazards to be grouped for purposes of storage, treatment, packaging, transportation, and/or disposal. As recommended in the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements' Report No. 139, Risk-Based Classification of Radioactive and Hazardous Chemical Wastes, a preferred classification system would be based primarily on the health risks to the public that arise from waste disposal and secondarily on other attributes such as the near-term practicalities of managing a waste, i.e., the waste classification system would be risk informed. The current U.S. radioactive waste classification system is not risk informed because key definitions--especially that of high-level waste--are based on the source of the waste instead of its inherent characteristics related to risk. A second important reason for concluding the existing U.S. radioactive waste classification system is not risk informed is there are no general principles or provisions for exempting materials from being classified as radioactive waste which would then allow management without regard to its radioactivity. This paper elaborates the current system for classifying and reclassifying radioactive wastes in the United States, analyzes the extent to which the system is risk informed and the ramifications of its not being so, and provides observations on potential future direction of efforts to address shortcomings in the U.S. radioactive waste classification system as of 2004.
放射性废物分类系统已被开发出来,以便将具有相似危害的废物归为一组,用于储存、处理、包装、运输和/或处置。正如美国国家辐射防护与测量委员会第139号报告《基于风险的放射性和危险化学废物分类》中所建议的,一个理想的分类系统应主要基于废物处置对公众造成的健康风险,其次基于其他属性,如管理废物的近期实际情况,即废物分类系统应以风险为依据。美国现行的放射性废物分类系统并非以风险为依据,因为关键定义——尤其是高放废物的定义——是基于废物的来源,而非其与风险相关的固有特性。得出美国现行放射性废物分类系统并非以风险为依据的第二个重要原因是,没有一般原则或规定可将某些材料豁免于被归类为放射性废物,从而允许在不考虑其放射性的情况下进行管理。本文阐述了美国现行的放射性废物分类和重新分类系统,分析了该系统以风险为依据的程度及其并非如此的后果,并对截至2004年解决美国放射性废物分类系统缺陷的潜在未来努力方向提出了看法。