Frick Ulrich, Rehm Jürgen, Kovacic Susanne, Ammann Jeannine, Uchtenhagen Ambros
Research Institute for Addiction and Public Health, Zurich, Switzerland.
Addiction. 2006 Nov;101(11):1631-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1360-0443.2006.01569.x.
To assess the efficacy and safety of orally administered heroin [diacetylmorphine (DAM)] tablets in substitution treatment of severely addicted opioid users.
An open-label, prospective cohort study with two non-randomly assigned treatment arms and historical controls: DAM tablets only versus DAM tablets combined with injected DAM and/or other opioids, with an observation period of 1 year.
Twenty-one out-patient treatment centres of the Swiss heroin-assisted treatment programme.
A total of 128 patients received DAM tablets only, and 237 patients received a combination of orally and intravenously applied DAM and other opioids.
Retention rate after 1 year; number of serious adverse events; dosage of DAM over time; subjective tolerance of study medication.
In the intention-to-treat analysis, 1-year retention rates after 1 year in the DAM tablets-only group [0.804, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.735-0.873] as well as in the subgroup combining oral application of DAM with intravenous application or other opioids (0.843, 95% CI = 0.797-0.889) were higher compared to historical controls (Swiss cohort of patients who had been substituted intravenously with DAM; 1-year retention rate = 0.70). Rates of serious adverse events under study medication (tablets only = 0.038 per application year; tablets in combination = 0.028 per application year) were comparable to the historical rate of the Swiss heroin-assisted treatment (0.043).
DAM tablets seem to be an effective and safe application mode of heroin-assisted substitution treatment. Randomized clinical trials to compare its relative efficacy to other substances are necessary.
评估口服海洛因[二乙酰吗啡(DAM)]片剂在重度阿片类药物成瘾者替代治疗中的疗效和安全性。
一项开放标签的前瞻性队列研究,有两个非随机分配的治疗组和历史对照:仅使用DAM片剂组与DAM片剂联合注射用DAM和/或其他阿片类药物组,观察期为1年。
瑞士海洛因辅助治疗项目的21个门诊治疗中心。
共有128例患者仅接受DAM片剂治疗,237例患者接受口服和静脉应用DAM及其他阿片类药物的联合治疗。
1年后的留存率;严重不良事件的数量;随时间变化的DAM剂量;研究药物的主观耐受性。
在意向性分析中,仅使用DAM片剂组1年后的1年留存率[0.804,95%置信区间(CI)=0.735 - 0.873]以及将口服DAM与静脉应用或其他阿片类药物联合使用的亚组(0.843,95%CI = 0.797 - 0.889)均高于历史对照(瑞士静脉注射DAM替代治疗的患者队列;1年留存率 = 0.70)。研究药物治疗下的严重不良事件发生率(仅片剂组 = 每年每例0.038;联合片剂组 = 每年每例0.028)与瑞士海洛因辅助治疗的历史发生率(0.043)相当。
DAM片剂似乎是海洛因辅助替代治疗的一种有效且安全的应用方式。有必要进行随机临床试验以比较其与其他药物的相对疗效。