Ahmed Irfan, Boulter Matthew K, Lobo Dileep N
Sex Health. 2006 Sep;3(3):195-6. doi: 10.1071/sh06011.
Anecdotal observations among medical staff suggest that young women with periumbilical piercing presenting with right iliac fossa pain are more likely to have pelvic inflammatory disease than acute appendicitis because of an unconventional lifestyle. This audit was performed to test the validity of this prejudice.
The clinical data of all female patients aged 16-45 years admitted to a teaching hospital with suspected acute appendicitis were collected prospectively over six months. Patients who had undergone previous appendicectomy or gynaecological surgery, those with known Crohn's disease, or those on antibiotics at the time of admission were excluded.
107 patients with a median age of 29.7 years (range 15-45 years) were studied. Thirty-two patients had periumbilical piercing (Group A) and 75 patients did not (Group B). Fifty-nine out of 107 (55.14%) were operated upon. Ten (31.2%) patients in Group A had histologically confirmed acute appendicitis compared with 25 (33.3%) in Group B. Other diagnoses in Group A included non-specific abdominal pain (n = 13, 40.6%), urinary tract infection (4, 12.5%), pelvic inflammatory disease (4, 12.5%) and ovarian cyst (1, 3.1%). Corresponding figures for patients in Group B were 30 (40.0%), 8 (10.7%), 7 (9.3%) and 4 (5.3%) respectively. None of the differences between the two groups were statistically significant.
There was no difference in the frequency of a final diagnosis of acute appendicitis or pelvic inflammatory disease in female patients with and without periumbilical piercing. Health care professionals should not allow their clinical judgment to be prejudiced by the presence of body piercing.
医务人员的轶事观察表明,因生活方式不寻常,脐周穿孔的年轻女性出现右下腹疼痛时,患盆腔炎的可能性比急性阑尾炎更大。本次审计旨在验证这种偏见的正确性。
前瞻性收集一家教学医院6个月内收治的所有16 - 45岁疑似急性阑尾炎女性患者的临床资料。排除既往有阑尾切除术或妇科手术史、已知患有克罗恩病或入院时正在使用抗生素的患者。
共研究了107例患者,中位年龄为29.7岁(范围15 - 45岁)。32例患者有脐周穿孔(A组),75例患者无脐周穿孔(B组)。107例中有59例(55.14%)接受了手术。A组中10例(31.2%)患者经组织学确诊为急性阑尾炎,B组为25例(33.3%)。A组的其他诊断包括非特异性腹痛(n = 13,40.6%)、尿路感染(4例,12.5%)、盆腔炎(4例,12.5%)和卵巢囊肿(1例,3.1%)。B组患者的相应数字分别为30例(40.0%)、8例(10.7%)、7例(9.3%)和4例(5.3%)。两组之间的差异均无统计学意义。
有或无脐周穿孔的女性患者最终诊断为急性阑尾炎或盆腔炎的频率没有差异。医护人员不应因患者有身体穿孔而影响其临床判断。