Yost Beth, North Chris
Virginia Tech, USA.
IEEE Trans Vis Comput Graph. 2006 Sep-Oct;12(5):837-44. doi: 10.1109/TVCG.2006.184.
Larger, higher resolution displays can be used to increase the scalability of information visualizations. But just how much can scalability increase using larger displays before hitting human perceptual or cognitive limits? Are the same visualization techniques that are good on a single monitor also the techniques that are best when they are scaled up using large, high-resolution displays? To answer these questions we performed a controlled experiment on user performance time, accuracy, and subjective workload when scaling up data quantity with different space-time-attribute visualizations using a large, tiled display. Twelve college students used small multiples, embedded bar matrices, and embedded time-series graphs either on a 2 megapixel (Mp) display or with data scaled up using a 32 Mp tiled display. Participants performed various overview and detail tasks on geospatially-referenced multidimensional time-series data. Results showed that current designs are perceptually scalable because they result in a decrease in task completion time when normalized per number of data attributes along with no decrease in accuracy. It appears that, for the visualizations selected for this study, the relative comparison between designs is generally consistent between display sizes. However, results also suggest that encoding is more important on a smaller display while spatial grouping is more important on a larger display. Some suggestions for designers are provided based on our experience designing visualizations for large displays.
更大、分辨率更高的显示器可用于提高信息可视化的可扩展性。但是,在达到人类感知或认知极限之前,使用更大的显示器能将可扩展性提高多少呢?在单个显示器上表现出色的可视化技术,在通过大型高分辨率显示器进行扩展时,是否也是最佳技术呢?为了回答这些问题,我们进行了一项对照实验,研究在使用大型拼接显示器通过不同的时空属性可视化方法扩大数据量时,用户的操作时间、准确性和主观工作量。12名大学生在200万像素(Mp)的显示器上,或者使用32Mp的拼接显示器对数据进行扩展后,使用了小多重图、嵌入式条形矩阵和嵌入式时间序列图。参与者对地理空间参考多维时间序列数据执行了各种概览和细节任务。结果表明,当前的设计在感知上是可扩展的,因为按每个数据属性数量进行归一化后,任务完成时间会减少,且准确性不会降低。对于本研究中选择的可视化方法,不同显示器尺寸下设计之间的相对比较似乎总体一致。然而,结果也表明,在较小的显示器上编码更重要,而在较大的显示器上空间分组更重要。基于我们为大型显示器设计可视化的经验,为设计师提供了一些建议。