Yildirim Aysegul, Akinci Fevzi, Ates Metin, Ross Thomas, Issever Halim, Isci Emre, Selimen Deniz
Health Education Faculty, Marmara University, Kartal, Cevizli, Istanbul, Turkey.
Contemp Nurse. 2006 Oct;23(1):38-45. doi: 10.5172/conu.2006.23.1.38.
The Jefferson Scale of Attitudes Toward Physician-Nurse Collaboration is an established instrument to measure the perceived work relationship between physicians and nurses. The survey addresses areas of autonomy and decision making, interprofessional education and relations, psychosocial care, teamwork, and shared responsibility. The aim of this prelimiary study was to adapt the Jefferson Scale of Attitudes Toward Physician-Nurse Collaboration for use in Turkey and test its psychometric properties and utility in clinical and research practice.
The process of cross-cultural adaptation and validation followed the guidelines provided in the existing literature. First, three bilingual health professionals independently translated the original questionnaire into Turkish and a consensus version was generated. Then, three other translators, blind to the original questionnaire, performed a back translation into English to confirm the accuracy of the translation. This version was then compared with the original English questionnaire. Discrepancies were discussed and solved by a panel of two nurses and two physicians. The field-testing for face validity was done in a group of ten monolingual physicians and nurses. Reliability was assessed with test-retest reliability and construct validity was confirmed with factor analysis.
The mean time of questionnaire administration was 3 minutes and 45 seconds. The test-retest reliability was 0.75, and Cronbach's coefficient alpha was 0.71 for the entire sample. The findings of the factor analysis indicated that the Turkish version of Jefferson Scale of Attitudes Toward Physician-Nurse Collaboration was comprised of the following four factors: 'physician-nurse relationships', 'shared education', 'nursing role in patient care', and 'accountability and responsibility of nurses.'
The overall findings of this study indicate that the Turkish version of the Jefferson Scale of Attitudes Toward Physician-Nurse Collaboration is a psychometrically sound tool with satisfactory measurement characteristics including construct validity and internal consistency reliability. This instrument may be useful in assessing the effectiveness of educational programs designed to enhance collaboration between physicians and nurses, whether these programs are aimed at residents and graduate nursing students or practicing physicians and nurses.
杰斐逊医生 - 护士协作态度量表是一种用于衡量医生和护士之间感知工作关系的既定工具。该调查涉及自主权和决策、跨专业教育与关系、心理社会护理、团队合作以及共同责任等领域。本初步研究的目的是对杰斐逊医生 - 护士协作态度量表进行改编,以便在土耳其使用,并测试其在临床和研究实践中的心理测量特性及效用。
跨文化适应与验证过程遵循现有文献中提供的指南。首先,三名双语健康专业人员将原始问卷独立翻译成土耳其语,并生成一个共识版本。然后,另外三名对原始问卷不知情的翻译人员将其回译成英语,以确认翻译的准确性。此版本随后与原始英语问卷进行比较。由两名护士和两名医生组成的小组讨论并解决了差异。在一组十名单语医生和护士中进行了表面效度的现场测试。通过重测信度评估可靠性,并通过因子分析确认结构效度。
问卷发放的平均时间为3分45秒。重测信度为0.75,整个样本的克朗巴哈系数α为0.71。因子分析结果表明,土耳其版的杰斐逊医生 - 护士协作态度量表由以下四个因素组成:“医生 - 护士关系”、“共同教育”、 “护士在患者护理中的角色”以及“护士的问责制和责任”。
本研究的总体结果表明,土耳其版的杰斐逊医生 - 护士协作态度量表是一种心理测量学上合理的工具,具有令人满意的测量特性,包括结构效度和内部一致性信度。该工具可能有助于评估旨在加强医生和护士之间协作的教育项目的有效性,无论这些项目是针对住院医师和护理学研究生,还是执业医生和护士。