Bleakley Amy, Hennessy Michael, Fishbein Martin
Annenberg Public Policy Center, Annenberg School for Communication, University of Pennsylvania, 3620 Walnut Street, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2006 Nov;160(11):1151-6. doi: 10.1001/archpedi.160.11.1151.
To examine US public opinion on sex education in schools to determine how the public's preferences align with those of policymakers and research scientists.
Cross-sectional survey.
July 2005 through January 2006.
Randomly selected nationally representative sample of US adults aged 18 to 83 years (N = 1096).
Support for 3 different types of sex education in schools: abstinence only, comprehensive sex education, and condom instruction.
Approximately 82% of respondents indicated support for programs that teach students about both abstinence and other methods of preventing pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases. Similarly, 68.5% supported teaching how to properly use condoms. Abstinence-only education programs, in contrast, received the lowest levels of support (36%) and the highest level of opposition (about 50%) across the 3 program options. Self-identified conservative, liberal, and moderate respondents all supported abstinence-plus programs, although the extent of support varied significantly.
Our results indicate that US adults, regardless of political ideology, favor a more balanced approach to sex education compared with the abstinence-only programs funded by the federal government. In summary, abstinence-only programs, while a priority of the federal government, are supported by neither a majority of the public nor the scientific community.
调查美国公众对学校性教育的看法,以确定公众的偏好与政策制定者和科研人员的偏好是否一致。
横断面调查。
2005年7月至2006年1月。
随机选取的18至83岁美国成年人全国代表性样本(N = 1096)。
对学校三种不同类型性教育的支持情况:仅禁欲教育、综合性性教育和避孕套使用指导。
约82%的受访者表示支持向学生传授禁欲以及其他预防怀孕和性传播疾病方法的项目。同样,68.5%的人支持教授如何正确使用避孕套。相比之下,在这三种项目选择中,仅禁欲教育项目获得的支持率最低(36%),反对率最高(约50%)。自我认定为保守派、自由派和温和派的受访者均支持禁欲加其他内容的项目,尽管支持程度差异显著。
我们的结果表明,美国成年人,无论政治意识形态如何,与联邦政府资助的仅禁欲项目相比,更倾向于一种更平衡的性教育方式。总之,仅禁欲项目虽然是联邦政府的优先事项,但既未得到大多数公众的支持,也未得到科学界的支持。