Zhang Yu-xing, Zhang Wei-hong, Lu Zhi-yue, Wang Ke-li
Department of Dentistry, Beijing Hospital, Beijing 100730, China.
Chin Med J (Engl). 2006 Nov 5;119(21):1815-20.
The increased use of all-ceramic crown provides a rationale for tooth-colored core. Due to superior mechanical properties, Vita Celay infiltration ceramic developed for crown and bridge works presents the potential for fabricating all-ceramic posts and cores in one piece. This study was conducted to compare the fracture strength of endodontically treated teeth which were thereafter given different types of posts and cores and crowns restoration, respectively. The evaluated post-and-core systems are: custom-fabricated Celay all-ceramic post-core, custom cast metal post-core, and prefabricated stainless steel post (Parapost) with and without 2.0 mm dentine ferrule.
Sixty freshly extracted human maxillary central incisors were endodontically treated and randomly divided into five groups with 12 samples each. Group A: Celay ceramic post-cores restored teeth with 2.0 mm dentine ferrule. Group B: Celay ceramic post-cores restored teeth with no dentine ferrule. Group C: cast metal post-cores restored teeth with 2.0 mm dentine ferrule. Group D: cast metal post-cores restored teeth with no dentine ferrule. Group E: prefabricated post and composite cores restored teeth with 2.0 mm dentine ferrule. All teeth were restored with Celay ceramic crowns. Each specimen was subjected to a load at a 45-degree angle to the long axis on MTS 810 material testing machine until failure, at crosshead speed of 0.02 cm/minute. Analysis of variance followed by the Newman-Keuls pairwise multiple comparison tests were used to compare the results of the groups tested.
There was a statistically significant difference among the five groups (P < 0.01). Celay ceramic post-cores restored teeth with 2.0 mm dentine ferrule [(758.35+/-19.26) N] and cast metal post-cores restored teeth with 2.0 mm dentine ferrule [(756.63+/-66.22) N] had a significantly greater mean fracture strength than the other three groups in which no significant difference was observed. The 2.0 mm dentine ferrule could cause significant fracture resistance alteration of Celay post-core restored teeth.
When covered with Celay ceramic crowns, Celay post-cores restored teeth with 2.0 mm dentine ferrule and cast metal post-cores restored teeth with 2.0 mm dentine ferrule have similar fracture strength. There was a statistically significant difference between the fracture resistance of Celay post-core restored teeth with and without 2.0 mm dentine ferrule.
全瓷冠使用的增加为牙齿颜色的核提供了理论依据。由于具有优异的机械性能,用于冠桥修复的维他灵铸瓷渗透陶瓷具有一体制作全瓷桩核的潜力。本研究旨在比较经根管治疗的牙齿分别采用不同类型的桩核及冠修复后的断裂强度。所评估的桩核系统包括:定制的维他灵铸瓷全瓷桩核、定制铸造金属桩核以及带或不带2.0毫米牙本质肩台的预成不锈钢桩(Parapost)。
60颗新鲜拔除的人上颌中切牙经根管治疗后随机分为五组,每组12个样本。A组:带2.0毫米牙本质肩台的维他灵铸瓷桩核修复的牙齿。B组:无牙本质肩台的维他灵铸瓷桩核修复的牙齿。C组:带2.0毫米牙本质肩台的铸造金属桩核修复的牙齿。D组:无牙本质肩台的铸造金属桩核修复的牙齿。E组:带2.0毫米牙本质肩台的预成桩及复合树脂核修复的牙齿。所有牙齿均用维他灵铸瓷冠修复。每个样本在MTS 810材料试验机上以与长轴呈45度角加载,直至破坏,横梁速度为0.02厘米/分钟。采用方差分析及Newman-Keuls两两多重比较检验来比较各测试组的结果。
五组之间存在统计学显著差异(P < 0.01)。带2.0毫米牙本质肩台的维他灵铸瓷桩核修复的牙齿[(758.35±19.26)N]和带2.0毫米牙本质肩台的铸造金属桩核修复的牙齿[(756.63±66.22)N]的平均断裂强度显著高于其他三组,而其他三组之间未观察到显著差异。2.0毫米牙本质肩台可导致维他灵桩核修复牙齿的抗折性能发生显著改变。
当用维他灵铸瓷冠修复时,带2.0毫米牙本质肩台的维他灵桩核修复的牙齿和带2.0毫米牙本质肩台的铸造金属桩核修复的牙齿具有相似的断裂强度。带与不带2.0毫米牙本质肩台的维他灵桩核修复牙齿的抗折性能之间存在统计学显著差异。