Jeyapaul Premkumar, Vieweg Ray
Wimborne and Purbeck community mental health team, Oakley bungalow 15 Oakley Lane, Canford Magna, Wimborne, Dorset, BH21 1SF, UK.
Ann Gen Psychiatry. 2006 Nov 29;5:20. doi: 10.1186/1744-859X-5-20.
The purpose of this case study was to use an evidence based medicine approach to work through an unusual way of treating a common problem. We looked at an example of an in-patient with severe refractory psychotic depression who had been resistant to treatment with a combination of antidepressant, antipsychotics, mood stabiliser, and concomitant ECT therapy. We then undertook a literature search for the use of clozapine in a patient with severe refractory depression. Although the resulting evidence was low level and thin, we felt on balance that a trial of clozapine was justified. We used a BPRS inventory to monitor her mood prior to commencing clozapine. Her mood and functional abilities were monitored as her clozapine was titrated upwards. Our patient showed a significant improvement in mood and functional abilities and a reduction in her BPRS score during this period. Her symptoms improved to the point where she was successfully discharged home on a combination of clozapine and an antidepressant. The improvement was sustained for a further two years. We thought this was an important case to highlight the limited evidence in using this successful form of treatment for a common clinical problem and that further research in this area was needed.
本案例研究的目的是采用循证医学方法,探索一种治疗常见问题的非常规方法。我们考察了一名患有严重难治性精神病性抑郁症的住院患者,该患者对联合使用抗抑郁药、抗精神病药、心境稳定剂及同步进行的ECT治疗均无反应。然后,我们针对氯氮平在严重难治性抑郁症患者中的应用进行了文献检索。尽管所得证据水平较低且不够充分,但总体而言,我们认为试用氯氮平是合理的。在开始使用氯氮平之前,我们用简明精神病评定量表(BPRS)对她的情绪进行监测。在逐渐增加氯氮平剂量的过程中,我们对她的情绪和功能能力进行监测。在此期间,我们的患者情绪和功能能力有显著改善,BPRS评分降低。她的症状改善到可以在氯氮平和一种抗抑郁药联合使用的情况下成功出院回家。这种改善持续了另外两年。我们认为这是一个重要案例,凸显了在针对这一常见临床问题采用这种成功治疗方式时证据有限,并且该领域需要进一步研究。