Coburn Kerry L, Lauterbach Edward C, Boutros Nash N, Black Kevin J, Arciniegas David B, Coffey C Edward
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Mercer University School of Medicine, Macon, Georgia 31201, USA.
J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci. 2006 Fall;18(4):460-500. doi: 10.1176/jnp.2006.18.4.460.
The authors evaluate quantitative electroencephalography (qEEG) as a laboratory test in clinical psychiatry and describe specific techniques, including visual analysis, spectral analysis, univariate comparisons to normative healthy databases, multivariate comparisons to normative healthy and clinical databases, and advanced techniques that hold clinical promise. Controversial aspects of each technique are discussed, as are broader areas of criticism, such as commercial interests and standards of evidence. The published literature is selectively reviewed, and qEEG's applicability is assessed for disorders of childhood (learning and attentional disorders), dementia, mood disorders, anxiety, panic, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and schizophrenia. Emphasis is placed primarily on studies that use qEEG to aid in clinical diagnosis, and secondarily on studies that use qEEG to predict medication response or clinical course. Methodological problems are highlighted, the availability of large databases is discussed, and specific recommendations are made for further research and development. As a clinical laboratory test, qEEG's cautious use is recommended in attentional and learning disabilities of childhood, and in mood and dementing disorders of adulthood.
作者评估定量脑电图(qEEG)作为临床精神病学中的一项实验室检查,并描述了具体技术,包括视觉分析、频谱分析、与正常健康数据库的单变量比较、与正常健康和临床数据库的多变量比较以及具有临床前景的先进技术。讨论了每种技术的争议点,以及更广泛的批评领域,如商业利益和证据标准。对已发表的文献进行了选择性综述,并评估了qEEG在儿童疾病(学习和注意力障碍)、痴呆、情绪障碍、焦虑、惊恐、强迫症和精神分裂症中的适用性。重点主要放在使用qEEG辅助临床诊断的研究上,其次是使用qEEG预测药物反应或临床病程的研究。突出了方法学问题,讨论了大型数据库的可用性,并对进一步的研究和开发提出了具体建议。作为一项临床实验室检查,建议在儿童注意力和学习障碍以及成人情绪和痴呆症中谨慎使用qEEG。