Hutchinson Paul, Wheeler Jennifer
Department of International Health and Development, School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana 70112, USA.
J Health Commun. 2006;11 Suppl 2:7-45. doi: 10.1080/10810730600973862.
While a considerable body of evidence has emerged supporting the effectiveness of communication programs in augmenting health, only a very small subset of studies has examined also whether these programs are cost-effective, that is, whether they achieve greater health gains for available financial resources than alternative interventions. In this article, we examine the available literature on the cost-effectiveness of health behavior change communication programs, focusing on communication interventions involving mass media, and, to a lesser extent, community mobilization and interpersonal communication or counseling. Our objective is to identify the state of past and current research efforts of the cost-effectiveness of behavior change communication programs. This review makes three principal conclusions. First, the analysis of the cost-effectiveness of health communication programs commonly has not been performed. Second, the studies reviewed here have utilized a considerable diversity of methods and have reflected varying levels of quality and adherence to standard cost-effectiveness methodologies. This leads to problems of transparency, comparability, and generalizability. Third, while the available studies generally are indicative of the cost-effectiveness of communication interventions relative to alternatives, the evidence base clearly needs to be expanded by additional rigorous cost-effectiveness analyses.
虽然已经出现了大量证据支持沟通项目在促进健康方面的有效性,但只有极少数研究同时考察了这些项目是否具有成本效益,也就是说,相对于其他干预措施,它们是否能利用现有的财政资源带来更大的健康效益。在本文中,我们研究了关于健康行为改变沟通项目成本效益的现有文献,重点关注涉及大众媒体的沟通干预措施,在较小程度上也关注社区动员以及人际沟通或咨询。我们的目的是确定过去和当前关于行为改变沟通项目成本效益的研究现状。本综述得出三个主要结论。第一,对健康沟通项目成本效益的分析通常尚未进行。第二,这里所综述的研究采用了相当多样的方法,并且反映出不同的质量水平以及对标准成本效益方法的遵循程度。这导致了透明度、可比性和普遍性方面的问题。第三,虽然现有研究总体上表明沟通干预措施相对于其他措施具有成本效益,但显然需要通过更多严格的成本效益分析来扩大证据基础。