Sookhoo S, Mackinnon I, Bushby K, Chinnery P F, Birchall D
Department of Neuroradiology, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Clin Radiol. 2007 Feb;62(2):160-5. doi: 10.1016/j.crad.2006.08.012.
To compare magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with clinical examination for the detection of muscle abnormality in patients with muscular dystrophy.
Muscle power in 20 patients with a variety of forms of muscular dystrophy was examined clinically using the Medical Research Council (MRC) grading scale, and patients were subsequently imaged with MRI. MRI and clinical examination for the detection of muscle normality and abnormality were compared using a McNemar chi-squared test to examine differences between the two methods.
MRI demonstrated radiological evidence of muscle abnormality more often than clinical examination; 50% of movements assessed as normal on clinical examination were associated with muscle abnormalities on MRI, including a significant proportion where there was severe radiological abnormality, indicating that focally advanced disease may be undetectable clinically.
The combination of clinical examination and MRI could improve the accuracy of phenotypic characterization of patients with muscular dystrophy, and this in turn could allow a more focussed molecular analysis through muscle biopsy or genetic investigation. This may also be very helpful in the assessment of the degree of muscle compromise not only in the early phases of the disease but especially during follow-up and can be used in therapeutic trials.
比较磁共振成像(MRI)与临床检查在检测肌营养不良患者肌肉异常方面的效果。
采用医学研究委员会(MRC)分级量表对20例患有各种形式肌营养不良的患者进行临床肌肉力量检查,随后对患者进行MRI成像。使用McNemar卡方检验比较MRI和临床检查在检测肌肉正常和异常方面的差异,以检验两种方法之间的差异。
MRI比临床检查更常显示出肌肉异常的影像学证据;临床检查评估为正常的运动中,50%在MRI上与肌肉异常相关,包括相当比例存在严重影像学异常的情况,这表明局部晚期疾病在临床上可能无法检测到。
临床检查和MRI相结合可以提高肌营养不良患者表型特征描述的准确性,进而可以通过肌肉活检或基因研究进行更有针对性的分子分析。这在评估肌肉受损程度方面可能也非常有帮助,不仅在疾病早期,尤其是在随访期间,并且可用于治疗试验。