Rauch Frank, Cornibert Sylvie, Cheung Moira, Glorieux Francis H
Genetics Unit, Shriners Hospital for Children and McGill University, 1529 Cedar Avenue, Montréal, Québec, Canada H3G 1A6.
Bone. 2007 Apr;40(4):821-7. doi: 10.1016/j.bone.2006.11.020. Epub 2007 Jan 12.
Cyclical intravenous pamidronate is a widely used symptomatic therapy in moderate to severe osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). The effects of treatment discontinuation on long bone development have not been characterized. In this observational study we used peripheral quantitative computed tomography to assess the radius at the distal metaphysis and at the diaphysis in 23 young OI patients (11 female) who had received pamidronate for at least 3 years. Measurements were performed twice, at the time of treatment discontinuation (when the age of the patients ranged from 5.9 to 21.3 years) and at an average of 1.9 years (range 1.5 to 2.4 years) later. At the time of pamidronate discontinuation, all but one of the patients who were below 15 years of age (n=14) had a positive age- and sex-specific z-score for bone mineral content (BMC) at the metaphysis, resulting in a mean z-score of +2.0 (SD=1.0) for this subgroup. In contrast, patients aged 15 years or older (n=9) had an average metaphyseal BMC z-score of -1.5 (SD=1.5). After pamidronate discontinuation, metaphyseal BMC z-score decreased by an average of 2.4 (SD=2.0) in the whole group. The change in BMC z-score was growth-dependent, as BMC z-scores decreased by about 2 or more in all patients in whom distal radius growth plates were open when pamidronate was discontinued. In contrast, none of the 11 patients with closed distal radius growth plates experienced a decrease in metaphyseal BMC z-score by more than 2. At the diaphysis, the average BMC z-score was low at the time of the last pamidronate infusion [z-score -1.7 (SD=1.4)]. After pamidronate discontinuation, the average diaphyseal BMC z-score decreased by only 0.3 (SD=0.4). In summary, this study shows that the effect of pamidronate discontinuation is much larger at the radial metaphysis than at the diaphysis and is dependent on growth. Metaphyseal bone tissue added by longitudinal growth after treatment discontinuation has a lower density than tissue created during treatment. It is possible that this produces zones of localized bone fragility after pamidronate treatment is stopped in growing children.
周期性静脉注射帕米膦酸盐是中重度成骨不全症(OI)中广泛使用的对症治疗方法。治疗中断对长骨发育的影响尚未明确。在这项观察性研究中,我们使用外周定量计算机断层扫描评估了23例接受帕米膦酸盐治疗至少3年的年轻OI患者(11名女性)远端干骺端和骨干的桡骨情况。测量在治疗中断时(患者年龄范围为5.9至21.3岁)和平均1.9年后(范围为1.5至2.4年)进行了两次。在停用帕米膦酸盐时,15岁以下的患者(n = 14)中除1人外,其余患者干骺端的骨矿物质含量(BMC)年龄和性别特异性z评分均为正值,该亚组的平均z评分为+2.0(标准差= 1.0)。相比之下,15岁及以上的患者(n = 9)干骺端BMC的平均z评分为-1.5(标准差= 1.5)。停用帕米膦酸盐后,全组干骺端BMC z评分平均下降2.4(标准差= 2.0)。BMC z评分的变化与生长有关,因为在停用帕米膦酸盐时远端桡骨生长板开放的所有患者中,BMC z评分下降约2或更多。相比之下,11例远端桡骨生长板闭合的患者中,没有一例干骺端BMC z评分下降超过2。在骨干,最后一次输注帕米膦酸盐时平均BMC z评分较低[z评分-1.7(标准差= 1.4)]。停用帕米膦酸盐后,骨干平均BMC z评分仅下降0.3(标准差= 0.4)。总之,这项研究表明,停用帕米膦酸盐对桡骨干骺端的影响远大于骨干,且与生长有关。治疗中断后纵向生长增加的干骺端骨组织密度低于治疗期间形成的组织。在生长中的儿童停止帕米膦酸盐治疗后,这可能会产生局部骨脆弱区域。