Earle Steven A, de Moya Marc A, Zuccarelli Jennifer E, Norenberg Michael D, Proctor Kenneth G
Dewitt-Daughtry Family Department of Surgery, Divisions of Trauma and Surgical Critical Care, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, Miami, FL, USA.
J Am Coll Surg. 2007 Feb;204(2):261-75. doi: 10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2006.11.014.
There are few reproducible models of blast injury, so it is difficult to evaluate new or existing therapies. We developed a clinically relevant polytrauma model to test the hypothesis that cerebrovascular resuscitation is optimized when intravenous fluid is restricted.
Anesthetized swine (42+/-5 kg, n=35) received blasts to the head and bilateral chests with captive bolt guns, followed by hypoventilation (4 breaths/min; FiO(2)=0.21). After 30 minutes, resuscitation was divided into phases to simulate typical prehospital, emergency room, and ICU care. For 30 to 45 minutes, group 1, the control group (n=5), received 1L of normal saline (NS). For 45 to 120 minutes, additional NS was titrated to mean arterial pressure (MAP) > 60 mmHg. After 120 minutes, mannitol (1g/kg) and phenylephrine were administered to manage cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP) > 70 mmHg, plus additional NS was given to maintain central venous pressure (CVP) > 12 mmHg. In group 2 (n=5), MAP and CPP targets were the same, but the CVP target was>8 mmHg. Group 3 (n=5) received 1 L of NS followed only by CPP management. Group 4 (n=5) received Hextend (Abbott Laboratories), instead of NS, to the same MAP and CPP targets as group 2.
Polytrauma caused 13 deaths in the 35 animals. In survivors, at 30 minutes, MAP was 60 to 65 mmHg, heart rate was >100 beats/min, PaO(2) was < 50 mmHg, and lactate was>5 mmol/L. In two experiments, no fluid or pressor was administered; the tachycardia and hypotension persisted. The first liter of intravenous fluid partially corrected these variables, and also partially corrected mixed venous O(2), gastric and portal venous O(2), cardiac output, renal blood flow, and urine output. Additional NS (total of 36+/-1 mL/kg/h and 17+/-6 mL/kg/h, in groups 1 and 2, respectively) correlated with increased intracranial pressure to 38+/-4 mmHg (group 1) and 26+/-4 mmHg (group 2) versus 22+/-4 mmHg in group 3 (who received 5+/-1 mL/kg/h). CPP was maintained only after mannitol and phenylephrine. By 5 hours, brain tissue PO(2) was>20 mmHg in groups 1 and 2, but only 6+/-1 mmHg in group 3. In contrast, minimal Hextend (6+/-3 mL/kg/h) was needed; the corrections in MAP and CPP were immediate and sustained, intracranial pressure was lower (14+/-2 mmHg), and brain tissue PO(2) was> 20 mmHg. Neuropathologic changes were consistent with traumatic brain injury, but there were no statistically significant differences between groups.
After polytrauma and resuscitation to standard MAP and CPP targets with mannitol and pressor therapy, we concluded that intracranial hypertension was attenuated and brain oxygenation was maintained with intravenous fluid restriction; cerebrovascular resuscitation was optimized with Hextend versus NS; and longer term studies are needed to determine neuropathologic consequences.
爆炸伤的可重复模型很少,因此难以评估新的或现有的治疗方法。我们开发了一种临床相关的多发伤模型,以检验以下假设:当限制静脉输液时,脑血管复苏效果最佳。
用麻醉枪对35头体重42±5千克的猪进行头部和双侧胸部爆炸伤,随后进行低通气(4次呼吸/分钟;吸入氧浓度=0.21)。30分钟后,复苏分为几个阶段,以模拟典型的院前、急诊室和重症监护病房护理。在30至45分钟内,第1组(对照组,n=5)输注1升生理盐水。在45至120分钟内,根据平均动脉压(MAP)>60 mmHg滴定额外的生理盐水。120分钟后,给予甘露醇(1克/千克)和去氧肾上腺素以维持脑灌注压(CPP)>70 mmHg,并给予额外的生理盐水以维持中心静脉压(CVP)>12 mmHg。第2组(n=5)的MAP和CPP目标相同,但CVP目标为>8 mmHg。第3组(n=5)先输注1升生理盐水,随后仅进行CPP管理。第4组(n=5)输注贺斯(雅培实验室),而非生理盐水,使其MAP和CPP目标与第2组相同。
35只动物中有13只因多发伤死亡。在存活的动物中,30分钟时,MAP为60至65 mmHg,心率>100次/分钟,动脉血氧分压(PaO₂)<50 mmHg,乳酸>5毫摩尔/升。在两个实验中,未给予任何液体或升压药;心动过速和低血压持续存在。第一升静脉输液部分纠正了这些变量,也部分纠正了混合静脉血氧、胃和门静脉血氧、心输出量、肾血流量和尿量。额外的生理盐水(第1组和第2组分别为36±1毫升/千克/小时和17±6毫升/千克/小时)与颅内压升高相关,第1组升至38±4 mmHg,第2组升至26±4 mmHg,而第3组(接受5±1毫升/千克/小时)为22±4 mmHg。仅在给予甘露醇和去氧肾上腺素后才维持了CPP。到5小时时,第1组和第2组的脑组织氧分压>20 mmHg,而第3组仅为6±1 mmHg。相比之下,所需的贺斯最少(6±3毫升/千克/小时);MAP和CPP的纠正迅速且持续,颅内压较低(14±2 mmHg),脑组织氧分压>20 mmHg。神经病理学变化与创伤性脑损伤一致,但各组之间无统计学显著差异。
在多发伤并通过甘露醇和升压药治疗使MAP和CPP达到标准目标后,我们得出结论:限制静脉输液可减轻颅内高压并维持脑氧合;与生理盐水相比,贺斯能优化脑血管复苏;需要进行长期研究以确定神经病理学后果。