Smith Nicole P, Ba'ath Muhammad E, Perry Daniel, Morgan Larissa E, Lamont Graham L, Baillie Colin T
Department of Paediatric Surgery, Royal Liverpool Children's Hospital NHS Trust, Liverpool LI2 2AP, UK.
J Pediatr Surg. 2007 Feb;42(2):296-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2006.10.002.
A recent survey of children with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) identified wide regional variations of care within the UK. The present study was designed to analyse paediatric surgical provision for children with ulcerative colitis and Crohn's disease.
All UK paediatric surgical centres were contacted to identify surgeons with a subspecialist interest in IBD. A questionnaire was designed to probe specific areas including team working, caseload, and transitional care. Annual consultant caseload was requested for colonoscopy, J-pouch ileoanal anastomosis (IPAA) for ulcerative colitis, and strictureplasty (Crohn's disease). The questionnaire and the accompanying letter were approved by the BAPS Research and Clinical Effectiveness Committee.
The response rate from individual centres was 86% (25/29). In 11% of centres, care was shared between 2 consultants. A transitional care clinic was provided by 77% of centres. The median experience with IPAA was 0.9 cases per year of consultant practice (range, 0-3.7), and 12.5% of surgeons had limited experience of revision pouch surgery. The majority have arrangements for joint operating with adult surgeons for IPAA. Forty percent of surgeons reported experience with strictureplasty. Surgical preference for recalcitrant left-side Crohn's colitis favoured segmental resection (60%), compared to subtotal/panproctocolectomy.
Paediatric surgeons use a diversity of surgical management options in IBD. Experience with IPAA is limited for most surgeons. Whether children should undergo elective IPAA independent of experienced adult practitioners, who naturally assume responsibility after transition, requires careful debate.
最近一项针对炎症性肠病(IBD)患儿的调查发现,英国国内的医疗护理存在广泛的地区差异。本研究旨在分析针对溃疡性结肠炎和克罗恩病患儿的儿科手术供应情况。
联系了英国所有的儿科手术中心,以确定对IBD有亚专业兴趣的外科医生。设计了一份问卷,以探究特定领域,包括团队协作、病例量和过渡性护理。要求提供每年结肠镜检查、溃疡性结肠炎的J形贮袋回肠肛管吻合术(IPAA)以及狭窄成形术(克罗恩病)的顾问病例量。问卷及附带信件经英国小儿外科学会(BAPS)研究与临床疗效委员会批准。
各中心的回复率为86%(29个中心中的25个)。在11%的中心,由2位顾问共同提供护理。77%的中心设有过渡性护理诊所。顾问医生进行IPAA的年中位经验为每年0.9例(范围为0 - 3.7例),12.5%的外科医生对贮袋修复手术的经验有限。大多数中心安排了与成人外科医生联合进行IPAA手术。40%的外科医生报告有狭窄成形术的经验。对于顽固性左侧克罗恩病性结肠炎,手术首选倾向于节段性切除(60%),而不是次全/全直肠结肠切除术。
儿科外科医生在IBD中使用多种手术管理方案。大多数外科医生对IPAA的经验有限。对于儿童是否应在经验丰富的成人从业者(他们在过渡后自然承担责任)之外接受择期IPAA手术,需要进行仔细的讨论。