Langdon Robyn, McLaren Jen, Polito Vince, Coltheart Max, Ward Philip B
Macquarie Centre for Cognitive Science, Macquarie University, NSW, Australia.
Psychiatry Res. 2007 Mar 30;150(2):193-7. doi: 10.1016/j.psychres.2006.03.027. Epub 2007 Feb 8.
This study examined stimulus-driven and willed action in schizophrenic patients and healthy controls using an easy finger-tap task and a more demanding peg-placement task under unimanual, bimanual and dual-task conditions. Peg-placement externally cued by a metronome was also examined, as were practice effects. Patients with marked negative symptoms placed fewer pegs unimanually with and without practice and benefited most from metronome-cueing. Under dual-task conditions, when the participants placed pegs while concurrently finger-tapping, finger-tapping slowed down relative to unimanual scores in patients more than controls. Number of pegs placed also dropped off in controls and the patients with fewer negative symptoms. However, patients with more severe negative symptoms placed just as many pegs, and sometimes more, in the dual-task, compared to the unimanual, condition. These patients appeared to be using their finger-tapping just like an 'external' pacing-stimulus for peg-placement, thus rendering their peg-placement more stimulus-driven than willed. In contrast, patients with fewer negative symptoms and controls tried to self-generate maximal performance on both finger-tapping and peg-placement, with deleterious effects on both tasks. That the patients with marked negative symptoms performed best when their actions were more stimulus-driven than willed strengthens the case that negative schizophrenic symptoms reflect a disorder of willed action.
本研究通过一个简单的手指敲击任务和一个要求更高的插栓放置任务,在单手、双手和双任务条件下,对精神分裂症患者和健康对照者的刺激驱动动作和自主动作进行了研究。还研究了节拍器外部提示的插栓放置情况以及练习效果。有明显阴性症状的患者在有无练习的情况下单手放置的插栓数量都较少,并且从节拍器提示中受益最大。在双任务条件下,当参与者在手指敲击的同时放置插栓时,与对照组相比,患者的手指敲击相对于单手得分减慢。对照组和阴性症状较少的患者放置的插栓数量也有所下降。然而,与单手条件相比,阴性症状更严重的患者在双任务中放置的插栓数量相同,有时甚至更多。这些患者似乎将手指敲击用作插栓放置的“外部”起搏刺激,因此他们的插栓放置更多地是由刺激驱动而非自主意愿。相比之下,阴性症状较少的患者和对照组试图在手指敲击和插栓放置上都自我产生最大表现,这对两项任务都产生了有害影响。有明显阴性症状的患者在其动作更多地由刺激驱动而非自主意愿时表现最佳,这进一步证明了阴性精神分裂症症状反映了自主动作障碍这一观点。