Leventhal Adam M, Waters Andrew J, Boyd Susan, Moolchan Eric T, Lerman Caryn, Pickworth Wallace B
Department of Behavioral Science, University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, TX, USA.
Exp Clin Psychopharmacol. 2007 Feb;15(1):21-36. doi: 10.1037/1064-1297.15.1.21.
Gender differences in tobacco withdrawal are of considerable clinical importance, but research findings on this topic have been mixed. Methodological variation in samples sizes, experimental design, and measures across studies may explain the inconsistent results. The current study examined whether male (n = 101) and female (n = 102) smokers (> or =15 cigarettes/day) differed in abstinence-induced changes on a battery of self-report measures (withdrawal, affect, craving), cognitive performance tasks (attention, psychomotor performance), and physiological responses (heart rate, blood pressure, brain electroencephalogram). Participants attended 2 counterbalanced laboratory sessions, 1 following 12 hr of abstinence and the other following ad libitum smoking. Results showed that women reported greater abstinence-induced increases in negative affect, withdrawal-related distress, and urge to smoke to relieve withdrawal distress. In contrast, both genders reported similar abstinence-induced changes in positive affect and urge to smoke for pleasure. Men and women exhibited generally similar abstinence-induced changes in physiological and cognitive performance measures. In addition, gender did not moderate the association between withdrawal symptoms and baseline measures of smoking behavior and dependence. Abstinence-induced changes in withdrawal distress mediated the effect of gender on latency until the 1st cigarette of the day at trend levels ( p < .10). These findings suggest that there are qualitative gender differences in the acute tobacco withdrawal syndrome that may underlie gender-specific smoking patterns.
烟草戒断中的性别差异具有相当重要的临床意义,但关于这一主题的研究结果却参差不齐。研究样本量、实验设计以及测量方法的差异可能是导致结果不一致的原因。本研究调查了男性(n = 101)和女性(n = 102)吸烟者(每天吸≥15支香烟)在一系列自我报告测量指标(戒断反应、情绪、渴望)、认知表现任务(注意力、心理运动表现)以及生理反应(心率、血压、脑电图)方面因戒烟引起的变化是否存在差异。参与者参加了2次平衡的实验室测试,一次是在戒烟12小时后,另一次是在随意吸烟后。结果显示,女性报告称,因戒烟导致的负面影响、与戒断相关的痛苦以及为缓解戒断痛苦而吸烟的冲动增加更为明显。相比之下,两性报告称,因戒烟引起的积极情绪变化以及为获得愉悦而吸烟的冲动相似。男性和女性在生理和认知表现测量指标方面因戒烟引起的变化总体上相似。此外,性别并未调节戒断症状与吸烟行为和依赖的基线测量指标之间的关联。在趋势水平上(p < .10),因戒烟引起的戒断痛苦变化介导了性别对直至当天第一支烟的延迟时间的影响。这些发现表明,急性烟草戒断综合征存在质性的性别差异,这可能是特定性别吸烟模式的潜在原因。