Lombardi D P, Engleberg N C
Department of Internal Medicine, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor.
Am J Med. 1992 Jan;92(1):53-60. doi: 10.1016/0002-9343(92)90015-4.
In the 1970s, blood culture for obligate anaerobic bacteria became routine in most United States hospitals. Since then, various authorities have reported isolation of obligate anaerobes in 5% to 25% of blood cultures. Our experience suggests a much lower frequency; therefore, we retrospectively assessed the occurrence and significance of these cultures at our institutions.
Sixty-six patients at the University of Michigan Hospitals (UMH) and nine patients at the Ann Arbor Veteran's Administration Medical Center (AAVAMC) had one or more blood cultures positive for an obligate anaerobe between July 1, 1987, and December 31, 1988. Their medical records were reviewed retrospectively.
The proportion of positive blood cultures yielding obligate anaerobes was 3.2% at the UMH and 1.8% at the AAVAMC. The incidences of clinically significant anaerobic bacteremia at the two hospitals were 0.68 and 0.54 cases per 1,000 patient admissions. Among the 40 patients from whom significant isolates were obtained, 15 (38%) had a fatal outcome. Bacteroides and Clostridium species accounted for 90% of the isolates and all of the fatal cases. The source for anaerobic bacteremia was usually obvious; 30 of the 40 patients were given empiric antibiotic therapy for anaerobes. The gastrointestinal tract was the source in two thirds of the cases and was clearly implicated as the source of 80% of the fatal bacteremias.
The frequency of anaerobic bacteremia in our hospitals is much lower than was suggested in several large studies during the 1970s, probably reflecting a real decline in the incidence. The clinical features of our cases are similar to those of previous studies, and the mortality is still high despite the use of antibiotics effective against anaerobes. Since most patients were thought to have anaerobic infections at the time that cultures were obtained, they were usually treated empirically. Subsequent blood cultures positive for anaerobes infrequently influenced clinical management.
20世纪70年代,对专性厌氧菌进行血培养在美国大多数医院已成为常规操作。自那时起,各权威机构报告在5%至25%的血培养中分离出专性厌氧菌。我们的经验表明其发生率要低得多;因此,我们对我们机构中这些培养物的发生情况及意义进行了回顾性评估。
1987年7月1日至1988年12月31日期间,密歇根大学医院(UMH)的66例患者以及安阿伯退伍军人管理局医疗中心(AAVAMC)的9例患者有一次或多次血培养结果显示专性厌氧菌阳性。对他们的病历进行了回顾性审查。
UMH血培养结果为专性厌氧菌阳性的比例为3.2%,AAVAMC为1.8%。两家医院临床上有意义的厌氧菌血症发生率分别为每1000例患者入院0.68例和0.54例。在40例获得有意义分离株的患者中,15例(38%)死亡。拟杆菌属和梭菌属占分离株的90%,且所有死亡病例均由这两类菌引起。厌氧菌血症的来源通常很明显;40例患者中有30例接受了针对厌氧菌的经验性抗生素治疗。三分之二的病例中胃肠道是感染源,且明确显示80%的致命菌血症的感染源是胃肠道。
我们医院厌氧菌血症的发生率远低于20世纪70年代几项大型研究中所提示的,这可能反映了实际发生率的下降。我们病例的临床特征与先前研究相似,尽管使用了对厌氧菌有效的抗生素,但死亡率仍然很高。由于大多数患者在进行血培养时被认为患有厌氧感染,所以通常给予经验性治疗。随后血培养结果为厌氧菌阳性很少会影响临床管理。