Baird Anne Dull, Ford Marvella, Podell Kenneth
Department of Psychology, University of Windsor, 401 Sunset Avenue, Windsor, Ontario, Canada.
Arch Clin Neuropsychol. 2007 Mar;22(3):309-18. doi: 10.1016/j.acn.2007.01.005. Epub 2007 Feb 21.
Numerous studies outline discrepancies in neuropsychological test profiles in African American and European American samples, despite similarities on major background factors. In our clinical sample of convenience, African American and European American older adults did not diverge on age, years of formal education, or global cognitive impairment. We predicted that ethnic groups would differ on a financial index, reading, and naming measures, but not on form discrimination and health problem-solving tasks. Results showed the expected patterns with the exception of form discrimination, which was lower in the African American group. Ethnicity no longer predicted standing on financial and nonverbal discrimination measures once we adjusted scores to equate for word-reading ability. In contrast, ethnicity status continued to explain significant variance in confrontation naming following adjustment for reading. When ethnic groups were subdivided by sex, European American men tended to have the highest scores of all four subgroups despite having equivalent levels of education. Therefore, future studies should examine the impact of cognitive activity throughout adulthood on real-world function and neuropsychological test performance among groups defined by both ethnicity and sex. In conclusion, in African American and European American elders seen for clinical assessment, literacy appeared to be associated with discrepant scores on a measure of real-world financial knowledge and skill, as well as with differences in verbal and nonverbal neuropsychological measures.
众多研究概述了非裔美国人和欧裔美国人样本在神经心理学测试概况上的差异,尽管在主要背景因素上存在相似之处。在我们的便利临床样本中,非裔美国人和欧裔美国老年人在年龄、正规教育年限或整体认知障碍方面并无差异。我们预测不同种族在财务指数、阅读和命名测试上会存在差异,但在图形辨别和健康问题解决任务上不会有差异。结果显示了预期的模式,但图形辨别测试除外,非裔美国人组的该测试得分较低。一旦我们调整分数以平衡单词阅读能力,种族就不再能预测在财务和非语言辨别测试中的表现。相比之下,在调整阅读因素后,种族状况仍能解释在对质命名测试中的显著差异。当按性别对种族群体进行细分时,尽管教育水平相当,但欧裔美国男性在所有四个亚组中得分往往最高。因此,未来的研究应考察成年期认知活动对按种族和性别定义的群体在现实世界功能和神经心理学测试表现方面的影响。总之,在接受临床评估的非裔美国人和欧裔美国老年人中,读写能力似乎与现实世界财务知识和技能测试中的差异分数相关,也与言语和非言语神经心理学测试中的差异相关。