Montoya Teresa, Gurian Patrick L, Velázquez-Angulo Gilberto, Corella-Barud Verónica, Rojo Analila, Graham Jay P
Center for Environmental Resource Management, University of Texas, El Paso, Texas, USA.
Int J Hyg Environ Health. 2008 Mar;211(1-2):40-9. doi: 10.1016/j.ijheh.2006.12.001. Epub 2007 Mar 2.
This study assessed exposure to carbon monoxide from gas and wood heater emissions in a sample of 64 households in peri-urban residential areas in Ciudad Juárez, Chihuahua, México. Indoor and outdoor carbon monoxide concentrations and temperatures were monitored for a continuous period of 1 week at 1 and 6-min intervals, respectively. The moving average carbon monoxide concentrations were compared to the World Health Organization (WHO) standards for carbon monoxide. Sixty-seven percent of households with gas heaters and 60% of households with wood heaters exceeded a health-based standard at some point during the monitoring. The difference between indoor and outdoor temperatures was modestly correlated with average carbon monoxide exposure (r=0.35, p-value <0.01). Heater type may be a stronger determinant of exposure, as households with a particular heater model (the El Sol FM-210) were significantly more likely to be among the more highly exposed households (odds ratio of 4.8, p-value of 0.02). A variety of health effects were pooled and found at elevated frequency in the households that exceeded the 8-h standard of 9ppm (odds ratio=5.1, p-value=0.031). These results highlight the need for further efforts to identify and mitigate potentially hazardous carbon monoxide exposures, particularly in moderate-income countries with cooler climates.
本研究评估了墨西哥奇瓦瓦州华雷斯城城郊居民区64户家庭中燃气和燃木取暖器排放的一氧化碳暴露情况。分别以1分钟和6分钟的间隔对室内外一氧化碳浓度和温度进行了为期1周的连续监测。将移动平均一氧化碳浓度与世界卫生组织(WHO)的一氧化碳标准进行了比较。在监测期间,使用燃气取暖器的家庭中有67%、使用燃木取暖器的家庭中有60%在某些时候超过了基于健康的标准。室内外温度差异与平均一氧化碳暴露呈适度相关(r=0.35,p值<0.01)。取暖器类型可能是暴露的更强决定因素,因为拥有特定取暖器型号(El Sol FM - 210)的家庭更有可能属于暴露程度较高的家庭(优势比为4.8,p值为0.02)。汇总了各种健康影响,发现在超过8小时9ppm标准的家庭中其出现频率升高(优势比=5.1,p值=0.031)。这些结果凸显了进一步努力识别和减轻潜在有害一氧化碳暴露的必要性,特别是在气候较凉爽的中等收入国家。