O'Driscoll S W, Morrey B F
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1992 Jan;74(1):84-94.
We analyzed the results of seventy-one arthroscopies of the elbow in seventy patients who had been followed for an average of thirty-four months, in order to evaluate the risks and benefits of the procedure. Thirty-four arthroscopies were done for diagnostic purposes, fifteen were done for treatment, and twenty-two were done for both diagnosis and treatment. Overall, fifty-one (73 per cent) of the seventy patients benefited in some way. There were diagnostic benefits in thirty-six (64 per cent) of the fifty-six elbows in which diagnosis was an indication for the procedure, and there were therapeutic benefits in thirty (70 per cent) of the forty-three elbows in which treatment was intended or was performed although not planned. The procedure was of benefit in only eighteen (75 per cent) of the twenty-four elbows that had loose bodies, but it was successful in all elbows in which the loose bodies were not secondary to some other condition, including arthrosis. The procedure was also successful in all four elbows in which the loose bodies had been due to osteochondritis dissecans. In twelve (80 per cent) of the fifteen patients who had débridement (removal of flaps or loose fragments of articular cartilage) and in one of the two in whom a synovectomy had been performed, the treatment was successful. Seven (10 per cent) of the seventy patients had complications, none of which were major. Three patients (4 per cent) had a transient radial-nerve palsy after intra-articular injection of local anesthetic; four others had persistent drainage and negative cultures, but the drainage resolved with antibiotic therapy. In one of the four patients, a permanent flexion contracture of 15 degrees developed, and 10 degrees of flexion was lost.
我们分析了70例患者71次肘关节镜检查的结果,这些患者平均随访了34个月,目的是评估该手术的风险和益处。34次关节镜检查用于诊断,15次用于治疗,22次用于诊断和治疗。总体而言,70例患者中有51例(73%)在某种程度上受益。在以诊断为手术指征的56个肘关节中,36个(64%)有诊断益处;在计划或实际进行治疗的43个肘关节中,30个(70%)有治疗益处。该手术仅对24个有游离体的肘关节中的18个(75%)有益,但对所有游离体并非继发于其他疾病(包括关节炎)的肘关节均成功。该手术对所有4个游离体由剥脱性骨软骨炎引起的肘关节也均成功。在接受清创术(切除关节软骨瓣或游离碎片)的15例患者中的12例(80%)以及接受滑膜切除术的2例患者中的1例,治疗成功。70例患者中有7例(10%)出现并发症,但均非严重并发症。3例患者(4%)在关节内注射局部麻醉剂后出现短暂性桡神经麻痹;另外4例有持续引流且培养结果为阴性,但经抗生素治疗后引流停止。4例患者中有1例出现15度的永久性屈曲挛缩,且丧失了10度的屈曲度。