Gill D R, Morrey B F
Department of Orthopedics, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota 55905, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1998 Sep;80(9):1327-35. doi: 10.2106/00004623-199809000-00012.
Sixty-nine patients (seventy-eight elbows) who had rheumatoid arthritis were managed with a Coonrad-Morrey total elbow arthroplasty between 1981 and 1986. At the time of the present review, forty-one patients (forty-six elbows) were alive and had been followed for at least ten years after the procedure (Group 1). The remaining twenty-eight patients (thirty-two elbows) had died or had had a revision less than ten years after the procedure or had been followed for less than ten years (Group 2). The patients in Group 1 had a younger mean age at the time of the procedure, but all other preoperative parameters were similar for both groups. At the latest follow-up evaluation, 97 per cent of the elbows (forty-five of the forty-six in Group 1 and thirty-one of the thirty-two in Group 2) were not painful or were only mildly painful. The mean arc of flexion-extension was 28 to 131 degrees; this represents an increase of 13 degrees (15 degrees in Group 1 and 7 degrees in Group 2) compared with the preoperative value. The mean arc of pronation was 68 degrees, and the mean arc of supination was 62 degrees; this represents an increase of 21 degrees. The results for seventy-four of the seventy-eight elbows (all forty-six in Group 1 and twenty-eight of the thirty-two in Group 2) were considered satisfactory by the patients. One patient thought that the status of the elbow was unchanged compared with preoperatively, and three thought that it was worse. Seventy-six of the seventy-eight elbows had long-term radiographic evaluation; the two remaining elbows were excluded because a resection arthroplasty had been performed. There were two loose ulnar components; one was associated with an infection, and the other had been causing no symptoms at the time of the patient's death. In addition, both components were radiographically loose in an elbow that had had a revision without cement after a previous total elbow arthroplasty. Five bushings (7 per cent) were completely worn, and six (8 per cent) were partially worn. Complications occurred in eleven elbows (14 per cent) and were serious, necessitating reoperation, in ten (13 per cent). Delayed complications included three avulsions of the triceps, two deep infections, two ulnar fractures, and one fracture of an ulnar component. In addition, two elbows were revised because of aseptic loosening. No patient had persistent ulnar neuritis or serious skin complications. At the latest clinical follow-up evaluation, according to the Mayo elbow performance score, forty-three of the seventy-eight elbows had an excellent result; twenty-six, a good result; seven, a fair result; and two (both in Group 2), a poor result. The rate of survival of the prosthesis was 92.4 per cent, with 86 per cent good or excellent and 14 per cent fair or poor results.
1981年至1986年间,69例患有类风湿性关节炎的患者(78个肘关节)接受了Coonrad-Morrey全肘关节置换术。在本次回顾时,41例患者(46个肘关节)存活,且术后至少随访了10年(第1组)。其余28例患者(32个肘关节)在术后不到10年死亡、进行了翻修手术或随访时间不足10年(第2组)。第1组患者在手术时的平均年龄较轻,但两组的所有其他术前参数相似。在最近的随访评估中,97%的肘关节(第1组46个中的45个,第2组32个中的31个)无疼痛或仅有轻微疼痛。屈伸平均弧度为28至131度;与术前值相比,增加了13度(第1组增加15度,第2组增加7度)。旋前平均弧度为68度,旋后平均弧度为62度;增加了21度。78个肘关节中的74个(第1组全部46个,第2组32个中的28个)的结果被患者认为满意。1例患者认为肘关节状态与术前相比无变化,3例认为更差。78个肘关节中的76个进行了长期影像学评估;其余2个肘关节因进行了切除关节成形术而被排除。有2个尺侧假体部件松动;1个与感染有关,另1个在患者死亡时未引起症状。此外,在1例先前全肘关节置换术后未使用骨水泥进行翻修的肘关节中,两个部件在影像学上均松动。5个衬套(7%)完全磨损,6个(8%)部分磨损。11个肘关节(14%)出现并发症,其中10个(13%)严重,需要再次手术。延迟并发症包括3例肱三头肌撕脱、2例深部感染、2例尺骨骨折和1例尺侧假体部件骨折。此外,2个肘关节因无菌性松动而进行了翻修。没有患者出现持续性尺神经炎或严重的皮肤并发症。在最近的临床随访评估中,根据Mayo肘关节功能评分,78个肘关节中43个结果优秀;26个,良好;7个,中等;2个(均在第2组),差。假体生存率为92.4%,86%为良好或优秀,14%为中等或差。